Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XXV

How Much Fortune Can Do in Human Affairs and How to Resist Her

Chapter summary

Many think that the world is governed by fortune and by God in such a way that the prudence of men cannot correct it, and conclude that it is not worth sweating much: it is better to let oneself be governed by luck. Machiavelli confesses that he inclines in part to this opinion, which gained strength in his time because of the variation of great events; but, so that free will may not be extinguished, he judges that fortune is the arbiter of half of our actions and leaves the government of the other half, or almost, to us. He compares her to a ruinous river, which floods the plains and tears down trees and houses, and before which everyone flees; even so, in calm times, men can build embankments and dikes, so that, in flood, the river runs through a channel or its force is less harmful. Fortune shows her power where there is no organized virtue to resist her, and Italy is a field without dikes: if she were protected as Germany, Spain and France are, the flood would not have done what it did.

In particular cases, one sees a prince prosper today and be ruined tomorrow without having changed his nature. Happy is he whose way of proceeding accords with the quality of the times, and unhappy he whose way is at odds with them. Men go to glory and riches by different roads, with caution or with impetuosity, by violence or by art; of two cautious men one arrives and the other does not, and two of opposite temperaments may arrive equally. Whoever prospers by one road is ruined when the times change, because no one is so prudent as to know how to adapt: he does not turn from what nature inclines him to, and cannot be persuaded to leave the road that took him far.

The example is Pope Julius II, who always proceeded with impetuosity and found the times in accord. In the enterprise against Bologna, with Giovanni Bentivogli still alive, Venice did not approve of it and the king of Spain was negotiating with France over it; Julius moved in person, left Spain and Venice in suspense and dragged the king of France behind him, who could not deny him troops without injuring him. If he had waited to leave Rome with everything arranged, like any other Pontiff, he would never have left. And the brevity of his life did not let him see the opposite: if times of caution had come, his ruin would have followed.

Machiavelli concludes that it is better to be impetuous than cautious, because fortune is a woman, and to keep her down one must beat her and push her; she lets herself be won more by those who proceed in this way and, like a woman, is a friend of the young, who are less cautious and fiercer.

Analysis

The title. The chapter asks two questions, and the title keeps them together: how much fortune can do, and how one resists her. Machiavelli answers the first with a proportion, the half, and the second with two images, the river and the woman, which say different things: with the river one resists beforehand, with dikes; with the woman, on the spot, with boldness.

What Machiavelli shows here is that fortune governs part of what happens and leaves the other to us, and that this other part is defended by preparation made in calm times. The prince who falls did not change his nature: the time changed and he went on acting as always. Since no one changes nature easily, what remains is to prefer impetuosity to caution, because fortune yields more to the one who commands her with audacity.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz