Chapter summary
Machiavelli raises an objection to himself: if it is so hard to hold a new state, how did Alexander the Great become lord of Asia in a few years and, hardly having occupied it, die, without the state rebelling? His successors held it, and the only difficulty they had was born of their own ambition. The answer lies in the way principalities are governed: either by a prince and servants, who help govern as ministers, by his grace, or by a prince and barons, who hold that rank by the antiquity of their blood, have states and subjects of their own and are loved by them. The examples from his own time are the Turk, who divides his kingdom into sanjaks and changes the administrators as he pleases, and the king of France, set in the midst of an ancient multitude of lords loved by their subjects, whose preeminences he cannot remove without danger. The state of the Turk is hard to conquer, because no one there can open the door to the invader and one must rely on one's own forces, but once the Turk is defeated in the field and unable to remake armies, all that remains to fear is the prince's blood, and once that is eliminated, there is no one left to fear. That of France is easy to invade, by winning over a discontented baron, and hard to hold, because the barons remain, and one can neither satisfy them nor eliminate them. Darius's government was like the Turk's, and so Alexander first had to defeat him entirely and then had the state secure. The Romans, by contrast, suffered rebellions in Spain, France and Greece because of the many principalities there, until the memory of these was wiped out by the duration of the empire. Machiavelli concludes that Alexander's ease, and the difficulty of Pyrrhus and others, came not from the virtù of the victor, but from the nature of the conquered state.
Analysis
The title. The title is a question that contradicts the previous chapter: Machiavelli has just said that holding what one has conquered is hard, and he brings the case that seems to refute it. The answer shows that the rule of Chapter III depends on the kind of state to which it is applied.
What Machiavelli shows here is that the ease or difficulty of holding a state depends on how it was built, and not on the talent of the one who conquers it. Where all are servants of a single lord, it is hard to enter and easy to stay; where there are barons with power of their own, it is easy to enter and hard to stay. Alexander had it easy because Darius's state was of the first kind, and Pyrrhus and others had difficulty without lacking virtù.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz