Chapter summary
When acquired states are accustomed to living under their own laws and in liberty, Machiavelli says there are three ways of keeping them: ruin them, go and live in them in person, or let them live under their laws, drawing a tribute from them and creating within them a state of a few who will keep them friendly, because this government, created by the prince, knows it cannot subsist without his friendship and power. The Spartans held Athens and Thebes by creating a state of a few and lost them. The Romans destroyed Capua, Carthage and Numantia and did not lose them, and when they wished to keep Greece almost as the Spartans had, making her free and leaving her her laws, it did not work: they had to destroy many cities of that region. Whoever becomes lord of a city accustomed to living free and does not destroy it should expect to be destroyed by it, for it always has as a refuge, in rebellion, the name of liberty and its ancient institutions, as Pisa did so many years after having been put into servitude by the Florentines. Cities accustomed to living under a prince, once his line is extinct, do not know how to make one from among themselves nor how to live free, and so a prince conquers and secures them more easily. In republics there is more hatred and more desire for revenge, and the memory of ancient liberty does not let them rest: the safest way is to eliminate them or to go and live in them.
Analysis
The title. The title is long and states the subject in reverse: it does not ask how to conquer free cities, but how to govern them afterward. The phrase that weighs is "their own laws": the chapter deals with peoples who have a way of living that the conqueror did not make.
What Machiavelli shows here is that a city that has lived free keeps the memory of liberty, and that this memory is the force the conqueror fears most. That is why, of the three paths he lists, the safest is the ruin of the city. Peoples accustomed to obeying a prince are easier, because they do not know how to be free.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz