Chapter summary
Machiavelli does not want to leave aside an error from which princes defend themselves only with difficulty: flatterers, of whom courts are full, because men take such pleasure in what is their own and deceive themselves in it so much that they scarcely defend themselves from this plague. And whoever wants to defend himself runs the risk of being despised, for one escapes flattery only when men understand that they do not offend by telling the truth; but when everyone can tell it, respect is lacking. The way out is a third course: to choose wise men in the State and give only them the freedom to speak the truth, and only about what the prince asks. He must ask them about everything, hear their opinions and then deliberate alone, in his own way, making it clear that the more freely they speak, the more welcome they will be. Apart from them, he should listen to no one, follow what he has decided and be obstinate. Whoever does otherwise either rushes headlong because of flatterers or changes constantly because of the variation of opinions, and from this comes the low esteem in which he is held.
The modern example is Maximilian, the present emperor. Pre' Luca, a man of his, said that he consulted no one and never did anything in his own way. The emperor is reserved, does not communicate his secrets or ask for advice; but when he puts them into execution and they begin to be known, those around him oppose him and he gives up easily. What he does one day he undoes the next, and no one understands what he wants.
Therefore a prince must always take counsel, but when he wants, not when others want; he must be generous in asking and a patient listener of the truth, and if he perceives that someone, out of fear, withholds it, he must grow angry. Many judge that a prince held to be prudent is so because of the good counsel he has around him, and they are mistaken: a prince who is not wise by himself cannot be well advised, unless he puts himself in the hands of one single most prudent man, and in that case he would last a short time, because that governor would take his State from him. With more than one counselor, the unwise prince will never have united counsel nor know how to unite it, and each counselor will think of what is his own. Men always turn out bad, unless necessity makes them good. The conclusion is that good counsel is born of the prince's prudence, and not the other way around.
Analysis
The title. To "avoid" flatterers: Machiavelli does not say combat, he says avoid, as one avoids a contagion. He has already called flattery a plague, and the title sets the tone: it is not a matter of punishing the flatterer, but of organizing the household so that he has no one to speak to.
What Machiavelli shows here is that the flatterer is born of the vanity of those who govern and can be avoided only by an arrangement: a few wise counselors, chosen by the prince, who are allowed to tell the truth, and only when asked. The decision always remains with him, and it is from him that the quality of counsel comes, and not the other way around. Emperor Maximilian shows the opposite defect, that of one who hears everything and changes with every voice.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz