Chapter summary
Every prince should wish to be held merciful, and not cruel, but without misusing mercy. Cesare Borgia was held to be cruel, and that cruelty restored order to the Romagna, uniting it and bringing peace and loyalty; he was more merciful than the Florentine people, who, to escape the name of cruel, let Pistoia be destroyed. The prince must not fear the infamy of cruelty if with it he keeps his subjects united: with very few examples he will be more merciful than those who let disorders run, from which come killings and plunderings that offend the whole community, whereas the prince's executions offend only a private person. For the new prince it is impossible to escape that name, and Virgil has Dido excuse the harshness of her kingdom because it is new.
Hence arises the dispute: is it better to be loved or feared? One would wish to be both, but it is hard to join them, and it is much safer to be feared. Men are ungrateful, fickle, dissemblers, avoiders of danger, greedy for gain: they offer blood, goods, life and children while danger is far off and rebel when it comes. The prince who has founded himself only on their words is ruined, because friendship bought is deserved but not possessed. Love is held by a bond of obligation that men, being wicked, break whenever it suits them; fear, by a dread of punishment that never leaves. The prince must make himself feared in such a way as to escape hatred: respect his subjects' property and women and shed blood only with manifest cause, because men forget the death of a father sooner than the loss of a patrimony.
At the head of an army, one must not mind the name of cruel: without it one does not keep troops united. Hannibal led an enormous army, of countless nations, into foreign lands, and there was never dissension, in good or bad fortune, because of his inhuman cruelty; without it his virtù would not have sufficed. Writers admire the effect and condemn the cause. Scipio, a most rare man, saw his armies in Spain rebel because of his excessive mercy. Fabius Maximus called him in the Senate the corrupter of the Roman militia; when a legate of his destroyed the Locrians, Scipio neither avenged them nor corrected him. That nature would have stained his glory had he continued to command, but, under the government of the Senate, it remained hidden and served him as glory. Conclusion: men love at their own will and fear at the prince's will, and a wise prince must found himself on what is his and strive only to escape hatred.
Analysis
The title. The chapter is the most famous in the book because of the question that appears in the title, "loved or feared." But the first half of the title is the one that prepares the answer: cruelty and clemency are placed side by side, and Machiavelli already wants to show that clemency badly used produces more deaths than cruelty well used.
What Machiavelli shows here is that the prince must choose what depends on him, and what depends on him is the fear he imposes, not the love he receives. Love is a bond of obligation that men break when it suits them, fear is a dread of punishment that is not broken. The prince, however, must make himself feared without being hated: spare his subjects' property and women, and shed blood only with manifest cause. The cruelty he defends is that of few examples, and not continual violence.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz