Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XIII

Auxiliary, Mixed and Own Soldiers

Chapter summary

Machiavelli passes to auxiliary arms, those of a powerful man called in to help with his troops. They may be good in themselves, but for the one who calls them they are always harmful: if you lose, you are undone; if you win, you are their prisoner. The recent example is Pope Julius II: after seeing, in the Ferrara enterprise, the sad proof of his mercenaries, he allied himself with Ferdinand of Aragon, king of Spain, and failed to reap the fruit of that bad choice only because fortune gave him a third cause, the Swiss, who expelled the victors after the defeat of the auxiliaries at Ravenna. The Florentines, wholly unarmed, brought ten thousand French to Pisa and ran more danger than ever, and the emperor of Constantinople put ten thousand Turks in Greece and they would not leave again. Auxiliaries are more dangerous than mercenaries: they are already a united body and obey another, whereas mercenaries need time and occasion to do harm, because they were hired and paid by you. In mercenaries the most dangerous thing is cowardice; in auxiliaries, courage. That is why a wise prince prefers to lose with his own arms than to win with others'.

Machiavelli brings Cesare Borgia as an example: he entered the Romagna with French troops, took Imola and Forlì, passed to the mercenaries of the Orsini and the Vitelli, found them doubtful, eliminated them and kept his own, and his reputation rose at every step. He cites Hiero of Syracuse, who had his mercenaries cut to pieces, and the Old Testament: David refused Saul's armor and went to face Goliath with the sling and the knife. The arms of others fall off the body, weigh it down or bind it. Charles VII of France created companies of his own, of cavalry and infantry; his son, Louis XI, dissolved the infantry and hired Swiss, and that ruined French arms, which no longer venture without them. These mixed arms are worth more than purely mercenary ones and less than one's own. Machiavelli recalls that hidden evil is born unseen, like hectic fevers, and that the Roman Empire began to lose its strength when it began to hire Goths. He concludes that without arms of one's own no principality is secure, and that one's own are those composed of subjects, citizens or servants of the prince.

Analysis

The title. The chapter catalogs the three kinds of arms that were still missing: auxiliary, mixed and own. Like the previous one, the title is a map, and the reader sees that the order runs from the worst (that of the powerful ally) to the only one Machiavelli recommends (one's own).

What Machiavelli shows here is that a prince is master of himself only when the arms that defend him are his. Auxiliary arms are the worst, because the ally who comes to help is already organized and obeys another, and if he wins, the prince comes to owe him everything. Mercenaries, at least, the prince paid and chose. The way out is to have troops made of subjects, citizens or servants, and Machiavelli illustrates with what he calls recent examples (Julius II, Cesare Borgia, Charles VII) and ancient ones (Hiero, David, the Goths in Rome).

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz