Chapter summary
Of the remaining qualities, Machiavelli makes a single idea: the prince must flee what makes him hateful or contemptible, and then he runs no danger from the other infamies. What makes him hateful is taking his subjects' property and women; contemptible, appearing inconstant, frivolous, faint-hearted or irresolute. The remedy against conspiracies is not to be hated by the people: the one who conspires has only fear, and the discontented accomplice gains more by denouncing. Example: Annibale Bentivoglio, prince of Bologna, was killed by the Canneschi, and the people, who loved him, killed them all and went to Florence to fetch a Bentivoglio held to be the son of a blacksmith, to govern until the heir grew up. In France, the Parliament is a third judge that punishes the great and protects the small without weighing on the king: the prince should leave to others what displeases.
The objection is the Roman emperors, from Marcus the Philosopher to Maximinus: Marcus, Commodus, Pertinax, Julianus, Severus, Antoninus (whom he also calls Caracalla), Macrinus, Heliogabalus, Alexander and Maximinus. They had a third difficulty: the soldiers wanted a cruel and rapacious prince, to have double pay, and the peoples wanted quiet. The new ones preferred to please the soldiers.
Marcus, Pertinax and Alexander, just, came to a bad end, except Marcus, who inherited the Empire and was venerable. Pertinax, made emperor against the will of the soldiers, accustomed to license under Commodus, was hated and, being old, despised. Alexander, who never killed without trial, was held to be weak and governed by his mother, and the army killed him. Commodus, Severus, Antoninus and Maximinus were cruel and rapacious, and only Severus came to a good end: he was fox and lion. He persuaded his army to avenge Pertinax, marched on Rome without showing that he aspired to the Empire and was elected by the Senate, out of fear; Julianus was killed. He attacked Niger, emperor in Asia, and deceived Albinus with the title of Caesar, until he killed him in France. Antoninus, Severus's son, a soldier beloved by the army, was hated for killing people in Rome and in Alexandria and died at the hand of a centurion whose brother he had killed. Commodus, an easy heir, became cruel, made the soldiers licentious, fought as a gladiator in the theaters, and was hated and despised. Maximinus, a warrior elected by the army, was despised for having tended sheep in Thrace and hated for the cruelties of his prefects; Africa, the Senate, Italy and the army before Aquileia conspired against him. Heliogabalus, Macrinus and Julianus, vile, were soon extinguished.
Today princes have this difficulty less, without armies rooted in the provinces, save the Turk and the Sultan. Pertinax and Alexander erred by imitating Marcus, and Caracalla, Commodus and Maximinus by imitating Severus: the new prince must take from Severus what founds the state and from Marcus what preserves a state that is firm.
Analysis
The title. The chapter deals with the two evils that bring down a ruler, hatred and contempt, and answers the qualification of Chapter 17, "escape hatred": after treating the prince's personal conduct, Machiavelli says what matters most to one who governs, which is not to be hated or despised by the whole.
What Machiavelli shows here is that the prince holds on when the people neither hate nor despise him, because the one who conspires counts on the people being satisfied by his death. For this, he must not take property or women and must appear firm, and when he must choose between pleasing the people and the soldiers, he pleases whichever is more powerful. Goodness alone does not save: Pertinax and Alexander were just and fell, because they lacked the reputation that Severus had.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz