Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XVI

Of Liberality and Meanness

Chapter summary

The first quality on the list: it would be good to be held liberal, but liberality harms the prince. Used as it should be, no one notices it. To keep the name of liberal, the prince needs ostentation in everything, spends his goods, ends up burdening the peoples and levying taxes in every way, and becomes hated and little esteemed as he grows poor. Having offended many and rewarded few, he feels the first pinch and is in danger at any danger; on drawing back, he at once falls into the infamy of miser.

If he is prudent, he will not mind that name: with time he will be held more liberal, because his thrift makes his revenues sufficient and he defends himself without taxing the people. He gives, in practice, to all from whom he does not take, who are countless, and is miserly with the few to whom he does not give. In Machiavelli's times, only those held to be misers did great things; the others were eliminated. Julius II used the name of liberal to reach the papacy and then dropped it, to make war on the king of France without an extraordinary tax, paying with years of thrift. The present king of Spain, if he were held liberal, would not have made or won so many enterprises.

Two objections are answered. Did Caesar come to the Empire through liberality? Whoever is still rising needs it, whoever has arrived does not: Caesar, had he lived without moderating his expenses, would have destroyed the Empire. And many princes with armies were most liberal? There one spends what is others', from plunder, booty and ransoms, and one must give, or the soldiers will not follow, as Cyrus, Caesar and Alexander did; spending what is others' increases reputation, and only spending what is one's own harms. Nothing consumes itself so much as liberality: the more one uses it, the less one can use it, and the prince becomes poor, vile or rapacious and hated. Among everything he must guard against are contempt and hatred, and liberality leads to both. It is wiser, therefore, to keep the name of miser, an infamy without hatred, than that of rapacious, an infamy with hatred.

Analysis

The title. Machiavelli puts liberality beside meanness, as in the previous chapter, and then inverts the value: what the reader holds to be a virtue (giving) will be what ruins, and what he holds to be a defect (saving) will be what saves. The title already warns that they are two faces of the same account.

What Machiavelli shows here is that the prince's generosity is paid for by the governed, and not by him. If he wants to be held liberal, he spends what belongs to his subjects and ends up hated; if he saves, he defends the state without taxing the people and, with time, is seen as just. It is good to give lavishly only what is taken from others in war, never what belongs to one's own people.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz