Chapter summary
Everyone understands how praiseworthy it is for a prince to keep his word and to live with integrity and not with cunning. But the experience of Machiavelli's time shows that the princes who did great things were those who paid little heed to their given word and knew how to entangle men's minds, and that in the end they overcame those who founded themselves on loyalty. There are two ways of fighting: with laws, which is proper to men, and with force, proper to beasts. Since the first often does not suffice, the prince must know how to use both the beast and the man. The ancients taught this in a veiled way, telling that Achilles and other princes were raised by the centaur Chiron, half beast and half man: one nature without the other does not last.
From the beast the prince must take the fox and the lion, because the lion does not defend himself from snares and the fox does not defend himself from wolves. One must be a fox to know the traps and a lion to frighten the wolves, and whoever relies only on the lion does not understand the matter. That is why a prudent lord cannot and should not keep his word when it turns against him or when the reasons for the promise have ended. If men were all good the precept would not hold, but they are wicked and would not keep their word to him, and legitimate reasons to disguise the breach are never lacking. There are countless examples of peace treaties and promises annulled, and the one who came out best was the one who best used the fox; one must know how to disguise, be a great simulator and dissembler, and men are so simple that whoever deceives will always find someone willing to be deceived. Machiavelli gives a recent example: Alexander VI never did anything but deceive, swore as no one else did and kept his word less, and his deceptions always worked for him.
The prince need not have all the qualities (merciful, faithful, humane, religious, upright), but he must appear to have them: having them and always following them, they are harmful; appearing to have them, they are useful. He must have his mind ready to turn the other way if needed, because, to maintain the state, the new prince is often obliged to act against humanity, charity and religion. He should not depart from the good, if he can, but know how to enter into evil, if obliged. Let him take care that nothing comes from his mouth that does not seem full of these qualities, above all of religion, because men judge more by the eyes than by the hands: everyone sees what he appears to be, few feel what he is, and one looks to the end. The common people are carried along by what appears and by the result, and in the world there is nothing but common people. The chapter closes with a prince of the present day, "whom it is not fitting to name," who preaches nothing but peace and good faith, and who, had he kept the one and the other, would have lost his state and his reputation more than once.
Analysis
The title. "How princes should keep their word" promises a lesson in loyalty, and the chapter teaches the measure in which one may break it. The irony is that the title asks "how" to keep one's word, and the answer is "when not to."
What Machiavelli shows here is that the prince needs two natures, that of the man, who fights with laws, and that of the beast, who fights with force and cunning, and that keeping one's word at any cost is dangerous in a world in which others do not keep theirs. What one must have is the appearance of the good qualities, because men judge by what they see, and the result is what counts. He does not tell us to abandon the good: he tells us to know how to enter into evil when necessity obliges.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz