Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter IX

Of the Civil Principality

Chapter summary

Machiavelli passes to the second path of the previous chapter: the citizen who becomes prince of his homeland not by crime or intolerable violence, but with the favor of his fellow citizens. It is the civil principality, and to reach it one needs neither all virtù nor all fortune, but rather a fortunate cunning. In every city there are two humors: the people desire neither to be commanded nor oppressed by the great, and the great desire to command and oppress the people. From these two appetites one of three effects is born: principality, liberty or license. The principality comes from the people or from the great, according to which side has the occasion: the great, seeing that they cannot resist the people, choose one of their own to govern in his shadow; the people, seeing that they cannot resist the great, choose one to be defended.

Whoever rises with the help of the great holds on with more difficulty, because he has around him many who judge themselves his equals and he cannot command them as he wishes. Whoever rises with the people's favor stands alone, and almost no one around him fails to obey. The great cannot be satisfied honestly and without injury to others, but the people can, because the people's aim is more honest: the great wish to oppress, and the people wish not to be oppressed. A hostile people can never be made safe, because they are many, whereas of the great one can be safe, because they are few. The worst the people can do is abandon the prince; of the great one must also fear that they will come against him, because they have more foresight and cunning and save themselves in time. The prince must always live with the same people, but can do without those great men, making and unmaking them every day. Of the great, whoever binds himself to the prince's fortune should be honored and loved, if he is not rapacious; whoever does not bind himself through lack of spirit can be used, especially if he is of good counsel; whoever does not bind himself out of ambition should be treated as an open enemy. Whoever rises through the people must keep them as friends, which is easy, since the people ask only not to be oppressed. Whoever rises through the great must above all win the people, which is easy if he takes up their protection.

Machiavelli concludes that the prince needs to have the people as a friend, otherwise he has no remedy in adversity. Nabis, prince of Sparta, sustained the siege of all Greece and of a victorious Roman army, and it was enough for him to secure himself against a few. He answers the worn proverb that whoever founds himself on the people founds himself on mud: it holds for the private citizen who believes the people will free him, as happened to the Gracchi in Rome and to Giorgio Scali in Florence, not for the prince who knows how to command, has courage and is not cast down in adversity. These principalities are in danger when they are about to rise from the civil order to the absolute, that is, when the prince comes to govern through magistrates and is left dependent on their will. In quiet times everyone runs, everyone promises; in adverse ones, few appear. That is why the wise prince must see to it that his citizens always have need of the state, and then they will be faithful to him.

Analysis

The title. "Civil principality" is the one born inside the city, among equals, and not from conquest or crime: the prince rises with the favor of other citizens. The chapter trades the sword for politics, and the historical example nearly vanishes: what takes its place is a reasoning about who wants what.

What Machiavelli shows here is that in every city there are two sides with opposed appetites, and that the prince who relies on the people holds on better than the one who relies on the great. The people want only not to be oppressed and are easy to satisfy; the great want to command and are never content. That is why the prince must make the people his foundation and create the habit of their needing the state, so that in adversity they do not abandon him.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz