Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XI

Of Ecclesiastical Principalities

Chapter summary

Machiavelli now treats ecclesiastical principalities, the states of the pope. In them, he says, all the difficulties come before possession: they are acquired by virtù or by fortune, but afterward are held without either, sustained by ancient institutions of Religion, so strong that they keep the prince in power however he lives. Only these have states without defending them and subjects without governing them, and so only they are secure and happy. But, since they are ruled by higher causes, he declares that he will not discourse on them. Then he asks where the temporal greatness of the Church came from, which before Alexander VI almost no one esteemed, and tells the way.

Before Charles, king of France, passed into Italy, the region was divided among the pope, the Venetians, the king of Naples, the duke of Milan and the Florentines, who had two concerns: that no foreigner enter with arms and that none of them occupy more state. To restrain the pope they made use of the barons of Rome, divided into Orsini and Colonna, always quarreling and with arms in hand before the Pontiff. The popes lived on average ten years, too short a time to destroy one of the factions before the successor raised it up again. Alexander VI showed what a pope could do with money and arms, by means of Duke Valentino and the passage of the French; the intent was to enlarge the duke, but the Church inherited the result. Julius II found the Church great, the Roman barons cut down and the road to money open; he won Bologna, brought down the Venetians, expelled the French and kept the Orsini and the Colonna quiet, with no cardinals to incite them. Leo X, at last, received a most powerful pontificate, and from him Machiavelli hopes that, if his predecessors made it great with arms, he will make it venerable with goodness.

Analysis

The title. The "ecclesiastical principalities" are the territories governed by the pope. The chapter treats a case apart, in which the state holds almost on its own, sustained by Religion, and ends by speaking of the pope who reigns while Machiavelli writes.

What Machiavelli shows here is that the temporal greatness of the Church came neither from heaven nor from faith, but from money, arms and popes who knew how to cut down the barons of Rome. He says he will not speak of ecclesiastical principalities, out of respect, and then explains with facts of state how the pope became strong: it was Alexander VI, with his son, and Julius II, with his wars, who did what the earlier popes had not managed.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz