Chapter summary
There are two ways for a private citizen to become a prince that are explained neither by fortune alone nor by virtù alone: to rise by a wicked and nefarious path, or to be made prince by one's fellow citizens. The chapter treats the first, with two examples, one ancient and one modern, without discussing the merits, because "they are enough for one who might be obliged to imitate them." The ancient one is Agathocles, the Sicilian, born of a potter, who always led a wicked life but accompanied it with so much virtù of spirit and of body that he rose through the militia to praetor of Syracuse. Resolved to be prince and to hold by violence what had been granted him by agreement, he arranged the plan with Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general who was waging war in Sicily, gathered the people and the Senate one morning as if to deliberate on the Republic and, at a signal, had his soldiers kill all the senators and the richest men. He then occupied the principality without civil controversy, and, though defeated twice by the Carthaginians and besieged, he defended the city, attacked Africa and forced them to leave him Sicily.
Machiavelli observes that Agathocles owed nothing to fortune, since he came to the principality by the ranks of the militia, won with a thousand dangers. But to kill one's own citizens, betray friends, be without faith, without pity, without religion is not called virtù: it brings empire, not glory. The modern example is Oliverotto of Fermo, an orphan raised by his uncle Giovanni Fogliani and set to soldiering under Paolo Vitelli and afterward under Vitellozzo, his brother. Finding it servile to depend on others, he wished to take Fermo and wrote to his uncle saying he would return honorably, with a hundred horsemen. After some days at his uncle's house, he gave a solemn banquet, raised grave subjects about Pope Alexander and Cesare and, in leading everyone to a private chamber, had hidden soldiers kill Giovanni and the others. Then he besieged the supreme magistrate in the palace and made himself prince. Within a year he became fearsome to his neighbors, and fell only because he let himself be deceived by Cesare Borgia at Sinigaglia, where he was strangled with Vitellozzo, the master of his virtues and wickednesses.
How did Agathocles and others like him live secure, when so many could not hold the state even in peace? Machiavelli answers that cruelties can be well or badly used. Those well used, if it is permitted to speak well of evil, are committed all at once, out of the necessity of securing oneself, and are afterward converted into the greatest possible benefit of the subjects. Those badly used grow with time. Whoever takes a state should commit all his cruelties at once; whoever spreads them out, through timidity or bad advice, must keep the knife in his hand and can never count on his subjects. Injuries should be done all together, so that they offend less; benefits little by little, so that they may be better savored. And in adverse times the good the prince does is judged forced and earns him no gratitude.
Analysis
The title. "Wickedness" is Machiavelli's word for the crime by which one rises, and he chooses it strong: the path is "wicked and nefarious." The chapter poses a problem to the reader: there are those who come to power without fortune and without virtù in the full sense, and still hold on. Machiavelli tells the cases and draws from them a lesson about how and when to use cruelty, without saying that he admires it.
What Machiavelli shows here is that crime can give power but not glory, and that the one who lasts is the one who uses it only once, quickly and completely, and afterward governs for the benefit of his subjects. Cruelty that repeats creates a prince with a knife in his hand and subjects who never feel secure. What decides is the timing and the dose of the evil, not the fact of doing it.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz