Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter VI

New Principalities Won with One's Own Arms and Virtù

Chapter summary

Machiavelli asks that no one be surprised by the enormous examples he will use: men walk almost always on paths opened by others and act by imitation, but never reach the virtù of those they imitate. That is why the prudent man should follow the great and aim high, like the archer who, finding the target too far, aims above it so that the arrow may arrive. In entirely new principalities, holding the state costs more or less according to how more or less virtuous the conqueror is, and whoever relied less on fortune held on longer. Among those who became princes by their own virtù, the most excellent are Moses, Cyrus (the founder of the Persian empire), Romulus (the founder of Rome) and Theseus (the hero who gathered the Athenians). Of Moses he says one should not treat, since he was a mere executor of what God ordered him, and he at once goes on to treat them all together: when their actions and institutions are examined, they do not differ from Moses'.

What fortune gave these men was only the opportunity, the matter on which to impose the form they wished. Moses found the Israelites enslaved in Egypt, ready to follow whoever took them out of there. Romulus did not fit in Alba and was exposed at birth, so as to become king of Rome. Cyrus found the Persians discontented with the Medes, and the Medes soft from long peace. Theseus found the Athenians scattered. Whoever rises by these paths conquers with difficulty and holds with ease, because the difficulties arise from the new institutions he is obliged to introduce in order to found his state and his security. The innovator has as enemies all those who do well under the old order and as lukewarm defenders those who would do well under the new, partly out of fear of their adversaries, who have the laws on their side, partly because men believe in what is new only when they see a firm experience arise from it.

It remains to be seen whether these innovators stand on their own or depend on others: whether, to carry the work forward, they must beg or can use force. In the first case they end badly; in the second they rarely run danger. Hence armed prophets have won and unarmed ones have been ruined, because the people are fickle, easy to persuade and hard to keep persuaded. Savonarola, the friar who governed Florence in our times, fell with his new institutions as soon as the multitude stopped believing in him, with no means of holding those who had believed or of converting the unbelievers. Once the dangers, which all lie on the road, have passed, and the envious have been eliminated, the founder is left powerful, secure, honored and happy. The chapter closes with a lesser example, Hiero of Syracuse: from a private citizen, he was elected captain by the oppressed Syracusans and afterward prince, dissolved the old militia, formed a new one, exchanged old friendships for new ones, and with friends and soldiers who were his own could build any building. He labored much to conquer and little to hold.

Analysis

The title. "Arms of one's own and virtù" are the two things the prince holds in his hands and no one gave him: troops that are his and the capacity to act. Machiavelli opens the noblest group of new principalities, that of the founders, to show that even they depend on both. Virtù here is not the goodness of Christian morality, it is the strength of one who acts and faces fortune.

What Machiavelli shows here is that whoever founds a new state suffers at the beginning and rests afterward, and that the virtù of founding is not enough without the force to impose. Fortune delivers only an opportunity; recognizing and using it is the work of man. And a new idea without a weapon to sustain it lasts until the people stop believing, which is soon.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

4 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz