Chapter summary
Whoever becomes a prince by fortune alone rises quickly and holds on at great cost: he has no difficulty on the way, because he flies, and all the difficulties are born after he has been put there. These are those who receive a state for money or by the favor of the one who grants it, like the princes whom Darius placed in the Greek cities of Ionia and the Hellespont, or the Roman emperors who came to the throne by corrupting the soldiers. They depend on the will and fortune of the one who made them great, and neither know how nor are able to keep the rank: they do not know how, because one who has always lived as a private citizen does not usually know how to command; they are not able, because they have no friendly and faithful forces. States that arise suddenly have no roots that resist the first adverse season, unless the new prince has so much virtù that he afterward lays the foundations that others lay beforehand.
The two ways of rising each have a recent example. Francesco Sforza, from a private citizen, became duke of Milan by due means and great virtù, and held with little effort what he had won with a thousand afflictions. Cesare Borgia, Duke Valentino, conquered the state with the fortune of his father, Pope Alexander VI, and with it lost it, though he had done everything a prudent man should to put down roots. Machiavelli recounts Cesare's political life in order. Alexander could enlarge his son only by throwing Italy into disorder, and he made the king of France's coming easier by dissolving Louis XII's marriage. With the Romagna conquered, Cesare saw that the arms of the Orsini were not faithful and that France would not let him advance, and decided to depend no longer on others' arms: he bought the nobles who were partisans of the Orsini and the Colonna, scattered the Colonna, and the Orsini, gathered at Magione, he deceived with courtesies and gifts until their simplicity led them to Sinigaglia, where he eliminated them.
The Romagna was full of robberies and quarrels, commanded by weak lords. Cesare put at its head messer Ramiro d'Orco, a cruel and efficient man, with full powers, and the region became peaceful. Fearing the hatred for so much severity, he set up a civil tribunal and showed that the cruelty was the minister's: he had him cut in two pieces in the square at Cesena. For the future, he had four defenses against a hostile pope: eliminate the lines of the dispossessed lords, win the nobles of Rome, hold the greater part of the College of Cardinals and conquer so much empire, before Alexander's death, that he could resist alone. At his father's death he had done three and nearly the fourth. But Alexander died and Cesare fell ill, between two hostile armies, with only Rome consolidated. Even so the Romagna waited for him for more than a month. Machiavelli would not know how to censure him and proposes him for imitation by one who rises by fortune and others' arms. He accuses him of only one choice: at the election of Julius II, he should have blocked the cardinals he had offended, because whoever believes that new benefits make old injuries forgotten deceives himself.
Analysis
The title. "Others' arms and fortune" is the opposite of the previous chapter: borrowed troops and a state that came for free. The chapter is the longest of the block because the example, for Machiavelli, is the argument: he does not want to give a rule, he wants to show a man acting.
What Machiavelli shows here is that whoever comes to power by another's hand must do quickly what the founder does slowly: put down roots, have his own troops, win the people, eliminate those who can offend him. Cesare Borgia did all this in a few years and lost, and Machiavelli says the fault lay with fortune and a single error. That is why he sets him as a model of method, even for those who know how it ended.
Subscription
The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.
Questions on this chapter
To discuss
5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.
Test your reading
8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz