Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter III

Of Mixed Principalities

Chapter summary

The chapter treats mixed principalities, those in which a new state is added, as a member, to an old state of the conqueror. The difficulty comes from a natural rule: men change their lord willingly, believing they will improve, take up arms against the one who governs and discover afterward that they are worse off. The new prince must offend those he conquers, with soldiers and other injuries, and ends up with the offended as enemies and unable to satisfy those who brought him in, to whom he owes a favor. That is how Louis XII, king of France, took Milan at once and at once lost it: the forces of Ludovico Sforza alone were enough to take it from him the first time, and the second time it was necessary to have the whole world against him and to see the French armies driven out of Italy. Machiavelli then separates two cases. If the new territory is of the same region and the same language as the old, it is enough to extinguish the line of the previous prince and not alter laws or taxes, as with Burgundy, Brittany, Gascony and Normandy in France. If it is of different language, customs and institutions, there are three remedies: the conqueror goes to live there, as the Turk did in Greece; he sends colonies to one or two places that are the keys of the state, which cost little and offend only a few, poor and scattered, since men avenge light injuries and not grave ones; and he makes himself head and defender of the less powerful neighbors, weakens the powerful and prevents the entry of a foreigner of equal strength, like the Aetolians, who brought the Romans into Greece. The Romans did all this: they sent colonies, kept the Achaeans and the Aetolians without giving them more power, brought down the Macedonians, expelled Antiochus and saw evils from afar, like the physician who treats the hectic fever at the start. They made war in Greece so as not to make it in Italy, and rejected the advice of the wise men of Machiavelli's time, "Enjoy the benefits of time." Louis did the opposite. Brought to Italy by the ambition of the Venetians, he won Lombardy and the friendship of nearly all the lords of the peninsula, and then helped Pope Alexander VI occupy the Romagna, enlarging the Church and losing his friends, and divided Naples with the king of Spain instead of taking it alone. Machiavelli counts five errors, plus a sixth, that of ruining the Venetians, and closes with a rule: whoever makes another powerful ruins himself. He also recalls the conversation he had at Nantes with the cardinal of Rouen, when Cesare Borgia, Valentino, was occupying the Romagna, and says he told him the French did not understand the state.

Analysis

The title. "Of Mixed Principalities" names the case in which the new is joined to the old. It is the first long chapter of the book, and the reason is that here the real subject begins: what holds a conquered state. The example that dominates it is the failure of a real and recent king, and not a hero.

What Machiavelli shows here is that conquering is one thing and holding is another, and that the second is lost through carelessness. He assembles a list of rules (live on the spot, send colonies, support the weak against the strong, prevent the entry of another strong power, see evils from afar) and shows the king of France disobeying every one. The Romans are the model, and Louis XII is the counter-model.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz