Clavis Libri

The Prince · Chapter XII

The Kinds of Militia and Mercenary Soldiers

Chapter summary

Machiavelli concludes the part on principalities and passes to defenses and attacks. Every state, new, old or mixed, needs good foundations, and the principal ones are good laws and good arms; since there cannot be good laws without good arms, he sets the laws aside and speaks of arms. The prince's are his own, mercenary, auxiliary or mixed, and mercenary and auxiliary arms are useless and dangerous. Whoever founds his state on mercenaries is never firm: they are disunited, ambitious, undisciplined, faithless, brave among friends and vile before the enemy, and ruin is postponed only as long as the assault is postponed. They have no other love than a little pay, which is not enough to die for you. The ruin of Italy comes from having rested on them for so many years, and that is why Charles of France could take her "with chalk." Whoever said that the cause was the sins of the people spoke only half the truth: the sins were those of the princes.

Mercenary captains are either excellent, and then they aspire to greatness of their own, or they are not, and they ruin you. The remedy is for the prince to go in person and be the captain, and for the republic to send its citizens, replacing the ones who are no good and restraining with laws the ones who are too good. Rome, Sparta and the Swiss were armed and free; Carthage was nearly oppressed by her mercenaries, Philip of Macedon took the liberty of the Thebans, Francesco Sforza betrayed the Milanese who hired him, and his father suddenly left Queen Joanna of Naples unarmed. Florence escaped by luck, Venice had the captain Carmagnola killed so as not to be dominated by him and afterward lost at Vailà, in a single day, what had taken her eight hundred years to conquer. Finally Machiavelli tells how Italy came to this: with the Empire expelled and the priests and citizens who came to govern the cities knowing nothing of arms, they began to hire foreigners. These captains reduced the infantry, spared themselves fatigue and risk, and led Italy into slavery and disgrace.

Analysis

The title. The chapter opens the subject of the militia (a state's troops) and reviews the kinds of arms a prince can have, starting with the worst, that of mercenaries, who are soldiers fighting for pay. The title divides the subject into two parts: how many kinds there are, and why the first he examines is useless.

What Machiavelli shows here is that a state is firm only when its own men defend it, and that a soldier paid by another makes war a business: he flees when the war comes and oppresses when he wins. To prove it, he uses the recent history of Italy, which lost its territory by handing arms to captains who wanted only pay and a reputation of their own.

Unlock with a subscription

Subscription

The complete analysis of every chapter of The Prince comes with a subscription, along with the explanation of each quote, the quiz, the PDF guide, and the study workbook.

See the plansAlready subscribed? Sign in

Questions on this chapter

To discuss

5 questions to discuss in class, in a group or on your own, with a subscription.

Test your reading

8 questions on this chapter. Take the quiz