Clavis Libri

Theme in Utopia

Religion

Religion as practice and as institution: Church, worship, rite, clergy, Scripture, the sacred and the profane.

The Theme in the Work

Religion runs through the book by three doors. The first is More's own, who in the Letter to Peter Giles tells of a theologian, a pious man, who wants to be sent to Utopia and made bishop of the Utopians, and tells that he considers holy the ambition that is born of piety and not of the calculation of honor or profit. The second is the criticism of Book I, Section 3 and Book I, Section 4: at the cardinal's table, a friar-theologian takes offense at the jester who calls friars the greatest vagabonds; and Hythloday accuses the preachers who, when customs were slow to adjust to the rule of Christ, adjusted the rule to customs, like a leaden ruler, so that one can only be wicked with more safety.

The third is the center of the island. In Book II, Section 8 the reasons for the Utopians' ethics rest on religious principles: the immortal soul and the rewards and punishments after death. In Book II, Section 11 Hythloday describes a plural religion: some worship the Sun, the Moon or a planet, others a man of ancient virtue, and most believe in a single power, eternal and inexplicable. All agree on a supreme being, to whom the universe and providence are owed, whom they call in common Mithras. When travelers tell them of Christ, many join and are baptized, and they lack Christian priests. The tolerance comes from Utopus: each person follows the religion he wishes and tries to persuade the others only with reasons, without violence or insult, and whoever disputes with petulance is exiled or enslaved. The priests number thirteen per city, elected by secret ballot, with no power beyond honor; the temples are dark and without images; in battle, the priests pray for peace and restrain the slaughter. In Book II, Section 9 it is they, with the magistrates, who advise the incurably ill to leave life. In Book II, Section 4 the book notes, among those who live without producing in other nations, the multitude of priests and of the so-called religious.

Mithras was a Persian god of light and of pacts, whose cult spread through the Roman Empire, especially among soldiers. The book presents the name as that of the supreme being in the language of the island, without explaining the choice.

The island's tolerance is real and has a limit. Utopus forbade one thing only, that anyone should think that the soul dies with the body or that the world goes by chance (Book II, Section 11). Whoever thinks so is despised, without honor or office, but is not punished or forced to pretend, and may argue with priests and serious men. The reason is political before it is religious: whoever fears nothing after death has no restraint but the law. The book shows both things together, the freedom to believe and the contempt for the atheist, and does not decide. Nor does the final prayer decide: each Utopian asks God to correct him if he is wrong, and admits that God may want the variety of religions. A republic that thinks it has the best religion prays that someone will show it the best one.

Where It Appears

  • Letter to Peter Giles: The theologian who wants to be bishop of the Utopians and the ambition he calls holy.
  • Book I, Section 3: The friar-theologian and the jester, who calls friars the greatest vagabonds.
  • Book I, Section 4: The preachers who adjusted the rule of Christ to customs, like a leaden ruler.
  • Book II, Section 4: The multitude of priests and religious among those who live without producing.
  • Book II, Section 8: The religious principles that the Utopians' ethics joins to reason: the immortal soul and the rewards after death.
  • Book II, Section 9: Priests and magistrates advise the incurably ill to leave life, a point at which Utopian religion goes hand in hand with reason.
  • Book II, Section 11: The religions of the island, Mithras, the tolerance of Utopus, the priests who pray for peace in battle, the limit of the immortal soul and the common prayer.

Passages

The holy ambition of one who wants to go and preach to the Utopians.

For he considers holy the ambition that is born not from the calculation of honor or profit, but from the consideration of piety
Letter to Peter Giles: Thomas More to Peter Giles

The theologian who wants to be made bishop of the Utopians.

he decided to arrange rather to be sent by the Pontiff and even to be made bishop of the Utopians, held back by no scruple at having to obtain that bishopric by petitions
Letter to Peter Giles: Thomas More to Peter Giles

The leaden ruler, which bends to customs.

they adapted his teaching to customs, like a leaden ruler, so that in some way at least they might be joined
Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

All call the supreme being Mithras.

they judge that there is a supreme being, to whom the work of the universe and providence are owed. All call him in common, in the language of their country, Mithras.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

The Utopians join Christ, in part because of the common life.

I believe, however, that it also weighed not a little that they had heard that the life in common of his followers pleased Christ, and that it is still in use among the most genuine assemblies of Christians.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

To impose by force what one believes true is insolent and foolish.

But to demand by force and threats that what you believe true should seem so to everyone, this he judged insolent and foolish.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

The only limit: to think that the soul dies with the body.

Except that he forbade, solemnly and severely, that anyone degenerate so far from the dignity of human nature as to think that souls die with the body, or that the world is carried along by chance, providence being removed.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

Whoever thinks the opposite does not count among men.

Whoever feels the opposite, they do not even count him in the number of men, for having lowered the sublime nature of his soul to the vileness of a little animal body.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians

Perhaps God delights in the variety of religions.

Unless it is also his inscrutable will to delight in this variety of religions.
Book II, Section 11: The Religions of the Utopians