Clavis Libri

Questions · Utopia

Is Utopia a model to follow or a critique?

The book allows both readings and does not choose. As criticism, several institutions of the island answer evils of Europe that Hythloday pointed out earlier. The gallows for the thief (Book I, section 3) is answered by work and the lack of private possession, the court of conquering kings (Book I, section 4) is answered by cities that do not wish to enlarge their boundaries (Book II, section 1), and the idleness of the rich is answered by everyone's six hours of work (Book II, section 4).

As a model, however, the text brings signs of caution. The Utopians are watched on all sides (Book II, section 6), have slaves who do the dirtiest work (Book II, section 5), hire mercenaries to die in their place (Book II, section 10), and the narrator himself says that much seems absurd to him. In the end, More confesses that he cannot agree to everything, but that there are many things he would wish to see in his own cities (Book II, section 12). Utopia works, thus, as a question: what would have to change for More's society to be less unjust, and at what price.

More questions about Utopia

See all questions