The book asks the question and does not answer it. Morus argues that a man like Hythloday should put his knowledge at the service of public affairs, because from the prince a torrent of goods and evils flows over the people (Book I, section 2). Hythloday refuses for two reasons: princes think more of conquering new kingdoms than of governing well the ones they have, and counselors flatter, or think they know everything and do not accept another's idea (Book I, section 2). He imagines the council of the king of France to show that what he had to say would be received with deafness (Book I, section 4).
Morus replies that there is another philosophy, more civil, which knows its stage and plays its part in the play at hand, and that, when evil cannot be turned to good, it must be made as little bad as possible. Hythloday retorts that to approve reluctantly the worst decrees is to become an accomplice (Book I, section 4). The conversation ends when Hythloday takes the debate to money and property, and the book goes on to tell of the island. The two points of view stand.