Clavis Libri

Theme in The Prince

Power

Who commands and how: authority, dominion, tyranny, leadership, kingship, control.

The Theme in the Work

The Prince treats power as something that is won and, above all, kept, and the question that runs through it is what sustains a prince when the times turn. Chapter I draws the map: every dominion is a republic or a principality, and the principality is hereditary or new, acquired with others' arms or one's own, by fortune or by virtù. Chapter II shows the easy case: the prince of ancient blood has fewer reasons and less need to give offense, and so is more loved, and the duke of Ferrara resists the Venetians and the pope merely by being long established in his dominion. Chapter III shows the hard case, the state added to another: the conqueror must offend those he conquers, finds the offended to be his enemies and cannot satisfy those who brought him in, and that is how Louis XII took Milan at once and at once lost it.

The difficulty of holding depends on the nature of what is conquered. In Chapter IV, Machiavelli explains why the kingdom of Darius, governed by a prince and servants, was hard to conquer and easy to hold, whereas France, full of barons loved by their subjects, is easy to invade and impossible to secure. In Chapter V, cities accustomed to freedom are kept only by ruining them, living in them or leaving them their laws under a government of the few that depends on the prince. Chapters VI and VII separate those who rise by virtù, who conquer with difficulty and hold with ease, from those who rise by fortune and others' arms, who "fly" and only afterward meet the problems: Cesare Borgia did everything to put down roots and lost the state when his father died. Chapter VIII brings power seized by crime, which gives empire and not glory, and Chapter IX power given by fellow citizens, in which the desire of the great to command and that of the people not to be oppressed both weigh.

The test of strength comes in Chapter X: the prince who gathers an army and meets the enemy in the field sustains himself alone, and the one who only shelters behind walls depends on others. Hence the insistence on arms of one's own in Chapters XII and XIII, and the counterweight of Chapter XX, where the best fortress is not to be hated. Chapter XI is the limit of the reasoning: ecclesiastical principalities have states without defending them and subjects without governing them, and for that reason, says the text, only they are secure and happy. Chapter XXI adds that power also needs reputation, won through great enterprises, like those of Ferdinand of Aragon, and Chapter XXIII that it needs counsel without surrendering to it. Chapter XXIV closes the argument by returning to the beginning: only those defenses are good, certain and lasting which depend on yourself and on your virtù.

Power, in the book, is a relationship, not a thing the prince possesses: it lasts as long as the others (the people, the great, the soldiers, the neighbors) prefer not to overthrow him, and each chapter asks what they want from him. The text supports two answers about what guarantees that relationship. One is one's own strength, which Chapter X, Chapter XIII and Chapter XXIV set as the test of every state. The other is the goodwill of the people, which Chapter IX, Chapter XIX and Chapter XX set as what no troop can replace. The book does not choose between the two, and they depend on each other, because arms of one's own, according to Chapter XIII, are made of subjects, citizens or servants of the prince.

Where It Appears

  • Chapter I: The map of principalities: hereditary and new, by others' arms or one's own, by fortune or by virtù.
  • Chapter II: The prince of ancient blood keeps himself with little, because he has fewer reasons to offend and so is more loved.
  • Chapter III: The state added to another forces the conqueror to offend, and whoever makes another powerful ruins himself.
  • Chapter IV: The mode of government, prince and servants or prince and barons, decides whether the state is hard to conquer or hard to hold.
  • Chapter V: Cities that lived free are kept only by ruining them, living in them or leaving them their laws.
  • Chapter VI: The founder by virtù conquers with difficulty and holds with ease, because the difficulties come first.
  • Chapter VII: The prince by fortune rises quickly and holds at a cost, and Cesare Borgia loses what his father's fortune gave him.
  • Chapter VIII: Power seized by crime gives empire and not glory, and well-used cruelties are committed all at once.
  • Chapter IX: The civil principality depends on having the people as friend, and the two humors of the city decide from whom it is born.
  • Chapter X: The test of any principality: does the prince sustain himself alone or depend on the defense of others?
  • Chapter XI: Ecclesiastical principalities have states without defending them and subjects without governing them, and for that reason only they are secure and happy.
  • Chapter XX: The precautions of princes (disarming, dividing, fortresses) and the rule that the best fortress is not to be hated.
  • Chapter XXI: The prince's reputation is born of great enterprises and of declaring himself friend or enemy.
  • Chapter XXIV: Only those defenses are good, certain and lasting which depend on yourself and on your virtù.

Passages

Chapter I defines the two kinds of new principality.

either they are entirely new, as Milan was for Francesco Sforza, or they are like members added to the hereditary state of the prince who acquires them, as the Kingdom of Naples is for the king of Spain
Chapter I: How Many Kinds of Principalities There Are and How They Are Acquired

In Chapter II, the reason why antiquity protects the prince.

For the natural prince has fewer reasons and less need to give offense; hence it is natural that he be more loved.
Chapter II: Of Hereditary Principalities

In Chapter IX, the two appetites of which the city is made.

the people desire neither to be commanded nor oppressed by the great, and the great desire to command and oppress the people
Chapter IX: Of the Civil Principality

In Chapter X, what frees a strong city from attack.

A prince, therefore, who has a strong city and does not make himself hated cannot be attacked.
Chapter X: How the Strength of All Principalities Should Be Measured

In Chapter XX, the counterweight to every fortress.

the best fortress there is, is not to be hated by the people
Chapter XX: Whether Fortresses and Other Things That Princes Do Are Useful or Harmful

In Chapter XXIV, the summary of the argument.

only those defenses are good, certain and lasting that depend on yourself and your own virtù
Chapter XXIV: Why the Princes of Italy Have Lost Their States