Clavis Libri

Theme in The Prince

Politics

Life of the city and the state: government, regime, ideology, democracy, state tyranny, nation.

The Theme in the Work

The Prince treats politics as the art of preserving the state, and does so with a method declared in Chapter XV: to go after the effectual truth of the matter and not the imagination of it, because many have imagined republics and principalities that never existed. The Dedication gives the position of the one who writes: a man of low condition who discourses on the government of princes and answers the charge of presumption with the image of those who draw landscapes, who place themselves on the plain to see the mountains and on a mountain to see the plain (The Landscape Painter). To know the nature of peoples one must be a prince, and to know that of princes, one must be of the people.

Chapter I divides all states into republics and principalities, and Chapter II sets the republics aside to treat only the principality. Chapter V returns to them from the side of those who conquer them: a city accustomed to freedom always has as its refuge, in rebellion, the name of liberty and its ancient institutions. Chapter IX describes the ground of all politics, the two humors of the city, that of the people, who do not want to be oppressed, and that of the great, who want to oppress, and from them are born principality, liberty or license. Chapter XI shows Italian politics as seen from the Papal States, with the barons of Rome divided into Orsini and Colonna and the popes Alexander VI and Julius II making the Church a power, and Leo X receiving it powerful.

The second half treats politics as conduct. Chapter XVI advises the prince to accept the reputation of miser and to avoid that of rapacious. Chapter XIX teaches how to avoid hatred and contempt and cites the Parlement of France as a third judge, which punishes the great and protects the small without burdening the king. Chapter XXI says that neutrality leaves the prince as the prize of the victor and that prudence consists in taking the lesser evil as good. Chapter XXII and Chapter XXIII deal with those around the prince, ministers and flatterers, and give the criterion that good counsels are born of the prince's prudence, and not the reverse. Chapter XXIV concludes that the princes of Italy lost their states through sloth, and Chapter XXVI brings the aim of the book: a new prince who will give Italy new laws and new institutions.

The politics of the book is made of cases, not of a system: each chapter poses a question (how is Milan held? what to do with free cities? is the fortress useful?) and answers it with what happened to someone. The text supports two readings of whom it serves. In one, it is a handbook for the new prince, and the advice of each chapter holds as a rule of conduct. In the other, Chapter XXVI shows that what Machiavelli wants is a project for Italy, and the earlier chapters are the preparation of the one who would carry it out. The two coexist, and the point of contact is the Dedication: he sends the Medici what he knows so that the latter may understand in a very short time what took him years to learn.

Where It Appears

  • Dedication: The author places himself on the plain to see the mountains, and says that to know princes one must be of the people.
  • Chapter I: All states are republics or principalities, and the book will deal with the latter.
  • Chapter V: Cities that lived free keep the name of liberty and the ancient institutions as a refuge in rebellion.
  • Chapter IX: The two humors of the city, that of the people and that of the great, from which are born principality, liberty or license.
  • Chapter XI: The politics of the peninsula as seen from the Papal States and the barons of Rome.
  • Chapter XV: The method of the book: the effectual truth of the matter, and the distance between how one lives and how one should live.
  • Chapter XVI: Liberality is political, and the infamy of miser is the one that costs least.
  • Chapter XIX: Hatred and contempt as the danger of every prince, and the Parlement as a third judge.
  • Chapter XXI: Neutrality, alliances and the rule of taking the lesser evil as good.
  • Chapter XXII: The choice of ministers as the first test of a prince's prudence.
  • Chapter XXIII: Flatterers and the way to hear counsel without losing respect.
  • Chapter XXIV: The princes of Italy lost their states through sloth, not through fortune.
  • Chapter XXVI: The political aim of the book: new laws and new institutions to free Italy.

Passages

In the Dedication, the place of the one who writes.

to know well the nature of peoples one must be a prince, and to know well that of princes one must be of the people
Dedication: To Lorenzo de' Medici

In Chapter I, the classification with which the book begins.

All states, all dominions that have had and have power over men, were and are either republics or principalities.
Chapter I: How Many Kinds of Principalities There Are and How They Are Acquired

In Chapter XV, the method.

it has seemed to me more fitting to go after the effectual truth of the matter than the imagination of it
Chapter XV: Of Those Things for Which Men, and Especially Princes, Are Praised or Blamed

In the same chapter, the reason for the method.

there is so much distance between how one lives and how one should live that whoever abandons what is done for what should be done learns his ruin sooner than his preservation
Chapter XV: Of Those Things for Which Men, and Especially Princes, Are Praised or Blamed

In Chapter XXI, the position of one who declares himself.

A prince is also esteemed when he is a true friend or a true enemy
Chapter XXI: What a Prince Should Do to Be Esteemed

In Chapter XXIII, where good counsel comes from.

good counsels, from whomever they come, must be born of the prince's prudence, and not the prince's prudence of good counsels
Chapter XXIII: How Flatterers Should Be Avoided

In Chapter XXVI, what most honors one who rises anew.

Nothing does so much honor to a man who rises anew as the new laws and new institutions discovered by him
Chapter XXVI: Exhortation to Free Italy from the Barbarians