Who He Is
Francesco Sforza is the man the book uses three times, and each time for a different lesson: the private citizen who became duke of Milan by virtù and due means, the mercenary captain who betrayed the Milanese who hired him, and the example that whoever professes the art of war conquers and whoever despises it loses. The book sets him, in Chapter I, as the case of the entirely new state, and in Chapter VII as the contrast to Cesare Borgia, who rose by fortune and others' arms. What he wants is a state, and what he knows is war: it was armed that he rose from private citizen to duke. What the book says of his family, in Chapter XIV, is that his sons, by avoiding the fatigues and hardships of arms, from dukes became private citizens.
Francesco Sforza (1401-1466), a leader of mercenary troops, became duke of Milan in 1450.
Trajectory
In Chapter I, he is the example of the entirely new state: Milan for Francesco Sforza, alongside Naples for the king of Spain, and the book prefers the known case to the abstract definition.
either they are entirely new, as Milan was for Francesco Sforza, or they are like members added to the hereditary state of the prince who acquires them, as the Kingdom of Naples is for the king of Spain
In Chapter VII, he is the example of one who rises by due means and great virtù: from private citizen, he became duke of Milan and held with little effort what he had won with a thousand afflictions. In Chapter XII, the same man appears from the other side, that of the mercenary who makes himself master of the one who hired him: he betrayed the Milanese, who had called him against Venice and ended up dominated by him.
Francesco Sforza took power in Milan in 1450, after defeating the Venetians at Caravaggio, in 1448, in the service of the Milanese.
In Chapter XIV, the lesson is that of the art of war: whoever professes it conquers the state, whoever despises it loses it.
The first cause that makes you lose it is to despise this art; the cause that makes you win it is to profess this art. Francesco Sforza, by being armed, from a private citizen became duke of Milan; and his sons, by avoiding the fatigues and hardships of arms, from dukes became private citizens.
In Chapter XX, the family name returns from the side: the castle of Milan made more war on the House of Sforza than any other disorder of the state, and the chapter concludes that walls are not enough and that the best fortress is not to be hated by the people.
Francesco Sforza rebuilt the castle of Milan, which bears the family's name.
Themes Embodied
Francesco Sforza embodies Virtù in the sense of the book, the capacity of the one who acts and founds, and for that reason Chapter VII sets him as the contrast to one who rises by fortune. He embodies War, because Chapter XIV uses him as proof that the only art of one who commands is that of arms. And he touches Power from the side of the one who hires, the mercenary who makes himself master, which is the danger that Chapter XII warns against.
The book uses the same man for three lessons, and what changes is the point of view. Seen from the new prince, he is a model: he rose by virtù and held what he won. Seen from the Milanese, he is the danger that Chapter XII describes, the excellent captain who aspires to greatness of his own and disposes of the one who pays him. Seen from his sons, he is the lesson of Chapter XIV: what the father won by arms, the heirs lost by leaving them. Machiavelli does not reconcile the three things, and the force of the example lies precisely in being a single name for all of them.
Relationships
- Cesare Borgia: the contrast of Chapter VII, the one who rose by fortune and others' arms and lost, set against the one who rose by virtù and held.
- Agathocles: the other case of a private citizen's rise, but by crime and without glory, in Chapter VIII.
- Louis XII: the king who took Milan from the Sforza and lost it, in Chapter III, and whose troops drove out Ludovico Sforza in 1499.
- Ferdinand of Aragon: the king of Spain with whom Chapter I makes a pair, Naples added, set against Milan new.
- Machiavelli: the author who uses him as a known example of his own time, and not as an abstract definition.