Clavis Libri

Theme in The Prince

Fate and Free Will

How much of a person's life is already decided, by the gods, by fortune, by providence, or by chance, and how much depends on their own choice. It includes prophecy, oracle, luck, predestination, and the question of who answers for what happens.

The Theme in the Work

The theme is concentrated in Chapter XXV, but the book prepares it from the start. Chapter I already divides conquests between fortune and virtù, and Chapter VI gives fortune an exact role: she gave Moses, Cyrus, Romulus and Theseus the opportunity, and it fell to virtù to seize it. Chapter VII shows the other side, the prince who receives the state from fortune and depends on her to keep it: Cesare Borgia thought of everything that could arise from his father's death and never thought that, at the hour of it, he himself would also be close to death. Chapter XIII warns that, without arms of one's own, the principality is left wholly to fortune, and Chapter XIV tells the prince to exercise himself in peace, so that, when fortune changes, she may find him prepared. The Dedication brings the personal note: the author says that he endures, without deserving it, a great and continual malignity of fortune.

Chapter XXIV changes the culprit. The princes of Italy who lost the state, says the text, should not blame fortune but their own sloth: in quiet times they never thought that things could change, and in the storm they thought of flight. Chapter XXV gives the rule. Many think that the world is governed by fortune and by God in such a way that the prudence of men cannot correct it, and Machiavelli, who partly inclines to that opinion, judges that fortune may be the arbiter of half of our actions but leaves the other half, or nearly so, to us, so that free will may not be extinguished. The image is the river that floods and tears down, against which, in calm times, repairs and dikes can be made (The River of Fortune); Italy is a plain without dikes. Then comes the second idea: happy is the one who matches his way of proceeding to the quality of the times, and Pope Julius II, who always acted with impetuosity, found times suited to his temper. The chapter's conclusion is that fortune is a woman and lets herself be won by the impetuous and the young.

Chapter XXVI gives free will its share back in religious terms: Italy begs God for a redeemer, the prodigies that accompanied Moses are in sight again, but God does not wish to do everything, so as not to take from us free will and the share of glory that falls to us.

The theme has two readings in the text. In one, Chapter XXV is advice for action: if fortune rules over half, the other half is enough for the one who builds dikes and attacks. In the other, the same chapter says that no one changes his nature to keep up with the times, and so whoever prospered by one path is ruined when the times change, so that virtù does not cover every flank, as the death of Alexander VI shows Cesare in Chapter VII. The book erases neither, and the image of the river serves both: the dike makes a difference, and the river remains a river.

Where It Appears

  • Dedication: The author says he endures, without deserving it, the malignity of fortune, and offers the prince the only good he possesses, what he has learned.
  • Chapter I: States are acquired by fortune or by virtù, and the opening of the book already sets destiny beside man's capacity as a cause of power.
  • Chapter VI: Fortune gives the opportunity, and virtù seizes it; without one of the two, the other is in vain.
  • Chapter VII: Cesare Borgia plans everything except his own illness at the hour of his father's death.
  • Chapter XIII: Without arms of one's own, the principality is left wholly to fortune, for no state holds when it depends on the forces of others.
  • Chapter XIV: The prince prepares in peace for when fortune changes, exercising himself in war through hunting and the reading of histories.
  • Chapter XXIV: The Italian princes should not blame fortune but their own sloth.
  • Chapter XXV: Fortune is the arbiter of half of our actions; the river, the dikes, the times and the woman who is won.
  • Chapter XXVI: God does not wish to do everything, so as not to take away free will, and the share that falls to man is to act to free Italy.

Passages

In Chapter VII, what Cesare Borgia did not foresee.

he told me, in the days when Julius II was created, that he had thought of everything that might arise from his father's death and had found a remedy for all of it, except that he never thought that, at the hour of that death, he himself would also be close to death
Chapter VII: New Principalities Won with Others' Arms and Fortune

In Chapter XXIV, whom to blame.

let them not blame fortune, but their own sloth
Chapter XXIV: Why the Princes of Italy Have Lost Their States

In Chapter XXV, the thesis.

fortune may be the arbiter of half of our actions, but she leaves the government of the other half, or nearly so, to us
Chapter XXV: How Much Fortune Can Do in Human Affairs and How It May Be Resisted

In the same chapter, the image of the dikes.

I compare her to a destructive river that, when it rages, floods the plains, tears down trees and buildings, carries earth from one place and sets it down in another; everyone flees before it, everyone yields to its fury, unable to resist it; and, although this is so, it does not follow that men, when the times are calm, cannot take precautions, with repairs and with dikes
Chapter XXV: How Much Fortune Can Do in Human Affairs and How It May Be Resisted

In the same chapter, the limit of prudence.

for, if he changed his nature with the times and with circumstances, fortune would not change
Chapter XXV: How Much Fortune Can Do in Human Affairs and How It May Be Resisted

In Chapter XXVI, the share that falls to the one who acts.

the sea has opened, a cloud has shown you the way, the rock has poured water, here it has rained manna; everything has concurred in your greatness; the rest is up to you. God does not wish to do everything, so as not to take from us free will and the part of that glory which falls to us
Chapter XXVI: Exhortation to Free Italy from the Barbarians