Clavis Libri

Theme in Utopia

Politics

Life of the city and the state: government, regime, ideology, democracy, state tyranny, nation.

The Theme in the Work

Utopia treats politics from two sides that complete each other: what happens in a king's council and what would happen in a republic designed from scratch. Book I is the first side. In Book I, Section 2, Raphael Hythloday refuses to serve a prince and gives two reasons: kings care more about conquering new kingdoms than about governing well the ones they already have, and counselors approve only what the king's favorite has already said, out of flattery. In Book I, Section 4 he imagines the council of the king of France, where the talk is of how to hold Milan and recover Naples, and answers that the people choose a king for themselves and not for the king, and that to rule over beggars is to keep a jail.

Against him, Thomas More defends another philosophy, a "more civil" one, which knows its stage and plays the part of the play being performed, and concludes that, if the evil cannot be cured, it should be made as small as possible, by an indirect route. Hythloday answers that to dissemble is to be complicit and takes the discussion to the root: where there are private possessions and everything is measured by money, one cannot govern with justice. The question is left without a winner, and Book II becomes the answer that Hythloday gives with the island.

Book II shows a politics made of institutional design. The fifty-four cities are identical in language, customs and laws (Book II, Section 1). Every thirty families elect each year a magistrate, the syphogrant, and the prince, chosen by secret ballot from four names, governs for life, unless he is suspected of having aspired to tyranny (Book II, Section 3). No public matter is valid without three days of debate in the senate, and deliberating outside it is a capital crime, a rule meant to keep the prince and the tranibors from uniting against the people; and nothing is discussed on the day it is proposed, so that no one defends out of vanity what he said without thinking. In Book II, Section 9 the laws are very few and there are no lawyers or treaties with other peoples, and in Book II, Section 10 the diplomacy of war includes secret bounties for whoever kills the enemy prince.

In the last section (Book II, Section 12), Hythloday accuses the republics of today of being "a certain conspiracy of the rich," and the narrator, instead of rebutting, falls silent out of weariness with the other man and out of courtesy, and closes by saying that he would wish for more than he would expect to see in the cities of his own time.

The theme is not resolved in a thesis. Hythloday points to a council that asks only how to conquer, and Morus points out that a philosopher who does not speak the language of his audience goes unheard; the book leaves both standing. The island, for its part, is not only freedom: in Book II, Section 6, the eyes of all, fixed upon each person, impose the necessity of work, and whoever wanders beyond the limits without the prince's permission is brought back as a fugitive. The reader is left with two questions: whether politics is made from the inside, with tact, or from the outside, at the root, and how much control a republic can tolerate and still remain just.

Where It Appears

  • Book I, Section 2: The prince is the source of good and evil, and counselors concern themselves with war and flattery, not with governing.
  • Book I, Section 4: The council of the king of France, Morus's "more civil" philosophy and the root that Hythloday points to: private property.
  • Book II, Section 1: The island of fifty-four identical cities, which the conqueror Utopus surrounded with sea.
  • Book II, Section 3: The magistrates, the prince for life and the rules against conspiracy and against haste.
  • Book II, Section 6: The permission to travel and the eyes of all upon each person.
  • Book II, Section 9: The Utopians live with very few laws, without lawyers and without treaties, which shows a politics that dispenses with specialists and with the negotiation of pacts.
  • Book II, Section 10: War waged by art and guile, with bounties on the head of the enemy prince.
  • Book II, Section 12: The conspiracy of the rich and the end of the book: More does not agree to everything and wishes for more than he expects.

Passages

Kings concern themselves with conquering, and the prince is the source of everything.

For from the prince, as from a perennial spring, a flood of all goods and all evils flows over the whole people.
Book I, Section 2: Raphael's Travels

The people choose the king for themselves, and not the other way around.

the people choose a king for themselves, not for the king's sake, that is, so that by his labor and care they may live comfortably and safe from injuries
Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

The other philosophy, the one that knows the stage it stands on.

there is another philosophy, more civil, which knows its stage and, adapting itself to it, in the play that is being performed plays its part with propriety and decorum
Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

Deliberating outside the senate is a capital crime.

To take counsel about common affairs outside the senate or the public assemblies is held to be a capital crime.
Book II, Section 3: The Magistrates

The haste and vanity of those who defend what they said without thinking.

And so, out of a twisted and perverse shame, he would sooner sacrifice the public safety than the opinion others have of him, so as not to seem to have foreseen too little at the start. Yet it was his duty to foresee from the start, to speak with reflection and not in haste.
Book II, Section 3: The Magistrates

Hythloday names what he sees in the republics of today.

I perceive nothing but a certain conspiracy of the rich, who pursue their own advantage under the name and title of the commonwealth.
Book II, Section 12: The Praise of the Republic and More's Reply

More refuses to decide between what he wishes for and what he expects.

Meanwhile, though I cannot agree with everything that was said, by a man who is without doubt most learned and at the same time most expert in human affairs, I readily confess that there are very many things in the commonwealth of the Utopians that I would rather wish for than expect to see in our own cities.
Book II, Section 12: The Praise of the Republic and More's Reply