The Theme in the Work
The theme is born at a dinner table. In Book I, Section 3, at the house of Cardinal Morton, the lawyer praises the English justice that hangs thieves, as many as twenty on a single gibbet, and wonders that so many are left. Raphael Hythloday replies that the penalty is too cruel and does not solve anything: theft does not deserve death, and no punishment keeps from robbing a man who has no other way to live. He points to the causes, which are the maimed soldiers with no trade, the idle nobles with their bands of servants, dismissed to steal, and the sheep that drive out the farmers, and concludes that justice manufactures thieves in order to punish them. He recalls that God forbade killing, that the law of Moses punished theft with restitution, and that the same penalty for the thief and for the murderer pushes the thief to kill the witness. The alternative comes from the Polylerites, a people of Persia: the thief returns what he took, works on public projects and may be freed if he reforms. The lawyer says this would put the republic in danger, and everyone backs him, until the cardinal suggests trying it; then everyone begins to praise what they had scorned.
In Book I, Section 4 justice returns by the back door: the counselors draw up an inventory of ways to fill the treasury, with fines from forgotten laws, dispensations sold and judges won over, and Hythloday states that where there are private possessions and everything is measured by money, one governs neither with justice nor with prosperity.
Book II shows a law of another design. In Book II, Section 9 the laws are very few, because a few suffice for those who have been well raised, pettifoggers are excluded and each man pleads his own case. No law fixes the penalty for most crimes: the senate decrees according to gravity, and almost every grave crime leads to slavery, which the Utopians find more useful than death and which is eased for whoever shows repentance. They sign no treaties, because the fellowship of nature stands in for them. Among peoples, they undertake war only for causes they judge just (Book II, Section 10), and in Book II, Section 5 they call it a most just cause of war when a people holds empty land and denies its use to those who need it. In Book II, Section 12 Hythloday closes the question he opened in Book I: what justice is this, in which one who does nothing necessary lives in splendor and one who sustains the republic ends his old age in misery?
The book treats justice as a design of conditions, not only of punishments: Hythloday wants to remove the causes of theft before discussing the gallows. But the law of the island is not mild. Adultery brings heavy slavery and, for a repeat offender, death (Book II, Section 9), furtive lust before marriage is severely punished and the priests advise the incurably ill to depart from life. The text shows both faces together and does not choose. The dinner scene adds a third: the same proposal is scorned while the lawyer speaks and praised when the cardinal approves it, and the justice of laws appears as dependent on who defends it.
Where It Appears
- Book I, Section 3: The cardinal's dinner: the gallows, the causes of theft, the restitution of Moses and the example of the Polylerites.
- Book I, Section 4: Forgotten laws and sold dispensations in the list of expedients, and the justice that has no room where everything is measured by money.
- Book II, Section 5: Empty land as a most just cause of war, in the founding of the colonies.
- Book II, Section 9: The slaves, the sick, marriage, the penalties, the very few laws and the absence of lawyers and treaties.
- Book II, Section 10: War only for causes judged just and the justice of paying for heads to spare the people.
- Book II, Section 12: The question "what justice is this" and the conspiracy of the rich that makes private gain law in the name of the public.
Passages
The gallows is too cruel and too weak.
It is too atrocious to avenge thefts and yet insufficient to restrain them.
The justice that manufactures the thieves it punishes.
What else do you do, I ask, but manufacture thieves and punish them yourselves!
God forbade killing, and we kill for a trifling coin.
God forbade that anyone be killed, and we kill so easily for a little money taken!
The penalty of the Polylerites: to destroy the vice while preserving the man.
For thus anger is exercised in order to destroy vices while preserving men, and treating them in such a way that they must needs be good.
The very few laws of the Utopians.
They have very few laws. Indeed, very few suffice for those so instituted.
The pettifoggers excluded.
As for pettifoggers, who handle cases with cunning and argue the laws with craft, they exclude them absolutely, every one.
Hythloday's question about the justice of other nations.
For what justice is this: that some nobleman, or goldsmith, or usurer, or any other of those who do nothing, or whose trade is of such a kind that it is not greatly necessary to the commonwealth, should obtain a sumptuous and splendid life from idleness or from a superfluous business?