The Theme in the Work
Money is the subject that links the two halves of Utopia. In Book I the first example is wool. In Book I, Section 3, Raphael Hythloday tells how, where the wool is finest, nobles, gentlemen and even abbots enclose the land for pasture, tear down houses and drive out the farmers, who sell everything for almost nothing, steal, beg or are jailed as vagrants; with no farming, the prices of wool and cattle rise, because the sale is in the hands of a few rich men. This is the image of the sheep that devour men: the gain of one eats the sustenance of many. In Book I, Section 4 the same logic climbs to the throne: the imagined counselors invent ways to fill the treasury, and Hythloday answers with the Macarians, whose king swears never to hold more than a thousand pounds of gold, and concludes that where there are private possessions and everyone measures everything by money, one does not govern with justice.
Book II describes an island without money. In Book II, Section 4, Hythloday attributes to coinage a good part of the useless labor of other nations: where everything is measured by money, many empty arts must needs be practiced, mere servants of luxury. In Book II, Section 5, any head of household takes from the storehouses, without money, what he and his family need, because no one fears want, and what makes the animal greedy is the fear of lacking, whereas in man it is only pride. In Book II, Section 7, the senate of Amaurot works out what is left over in one city and lacking in another, and the cities share freely, without exchange; and the gold and silver that trade with foreigners brings in are put to the vilest use, in chamber pots and in slaves' chains, so that no one will become attached to them. This is the symbol the gold of the chamber pots, and the symbol the Anemolian ambassadors shows its effect: visitors covered in gold are taken for slaves.
The gold, however, does not vanish: the Utopians keep it as a war treasure. In Book II, Section 10 it pays foreign soldiers, the Zapoletes, and bounties on the head of the enemy prince, and they spend it without reluctance, because they keep it for this one use. In Book II, Section 12 Hythloday closes with the thesis: where no one owns anything, everyone is rich, and money, invented to open the way to sustenance, is what closes it.
The book does not condemn gold; it condemns the price that men's opinion gives it: nature, says Hythloday in Book II, Section 7, assigned gold no use that cannot be done without, and it was folly that put a price on rarity. The island does not eliminate the value of the metal, it only moves it to war, and the text sets out without comment that the same gold scorned at home buys murders abroad. The theme allows two readings. In one, poverty is a problem of distribution, not of production: the granaries of the rich would have grain for everyone in a year of famine. In the other, it is a problem of opinion: what counts is what is esteemed, and the Utopians learn to esteem what is useful. The text supports both, and leaves standing Morus's objection in Book I, Section 4: without the motive of gain, no one would work.
Where It Appears
- Book I, Section 3: The sheep and the wool: enclosure ruins the farmers and enriches a few.
- Book I, Section 4: The king's treasure, the maxim of Crassus, the Macarians and the saying that where everything is measured by money, one does not govern with justice.
- Book II, Section 4: The empty and superfluous arts, servants of luxury, which exist only where everything is measured by money.
- Book II, Section 5: The storehouses from which each head of household takes what he needs, without money.
- Book II, Section 7: The senate that shares out abundance, the gold in the chamber pots and in the chains, and the ambassadors taken for slaves.
- Book II, Section 10: The gold kept as a war treasure, which pays soldiers and bounties.
- Book II, Section 12: In the conclusion, the claim that "everyone is rich" shows money as what closes to man the way to sustenance.
Passages
The sheep, tame and eating little, have turned ravenous.
your sheep, which are usually so tame and feed on so little; now, it is said, they have begun to be so ravenous and untamable that they devour men themselves and devastate and depopulate fields, houses and cities.
A single glutton encloses adjoining fields, and the farmers are driven out.
Thus, so that a single insatiable and cruel glutton, a plague on his country, may join adjoining fields and enclose several thousand acres with a single fence, the tenants are driven out.
Where there are private possessions, one governs neither with justice nor with prosperity.
wherever there are private possessions, where everyone measures everything by money, there it will hardly ever be possible for the commonwealth to be managed either with justice or with prosperity
Any head of household takes, without money, whatever he asks for.
any head of household asks for what he and his family need and takes, without money, without any payment, whatever he asks for.
Gold and silver serve the most squalid uses.
For while they eat and drink from earthenware and glass, elegant indeed but cheap, they make chamber pots out of gold and silver everywhere, and every kind of the most squalid vessel, not only in the common halls but also in private houses.
Value comes from rarity, not from use.
to gold and silver nature assigned no use that we cannot easily do without, had not the folly of men put a price on rarity.
The leaden man and the wise men in slavery.
a fellow of lead, who has no more wit than a log and is no less wicked than foolish, yet has many wise and good men in slavery, only because a great heap of gold coins has fallen to his lot.
The gold kept for a single use, war.
But gold and silver, because they keep everything for this one use, they spend without reluctance, since they would live no less comfortably even if they spent it all.
No one owns anything, and everyone is rich.
And though no one owns anything, everyone is rich.
Money, invented to open the way to sustenance.
Sustenance could so easily be provided, were it not for that blessed money, which was certainly splendidly invented so that access to sustenance might be opened by it, and which alone closes the road to sustenance against us.