Clavis Libri

Theme in Utopia

Work and Vocation

Work and the calling: trade, profession, vocation, the dignity or the weight of work.

The Theme in the Work

The question of work appears first as vocation, and only then as organization. In the Letter to Peter Giles, Thomas More tells of his own day: courts, visits, wife, children and servants, and he writes only with the time he steals from sleep and meals. In Book I, Section 1, Raphael Hythloday appears as one who has chosen another life: he left his inheritance to his brothers and stayed in the fort, more eager to wander than for a tomb. In Book I, Section 2, Peter Giles asks him why he does not join a king, and Hythloday refuses the word serve; Thomas More argues that a man like him ought to put his learning at the service of public affairs. Vocation, here, is the question of whom one's knowledge is owed to.

Book I also shows the work that is missing. In Book I, Section 3 there are the idle nobles, who live like drones off the labor of their tenants, the dismissed servants who know only how to steal, and the maimed soldiers with no trade.

In Book II, Section 4 work is the rule for everyone. There is one common art, agriculture, taught from childhood, and one trade for each person, wool-working, linen, masonry, smithing or carpentry; whoever feels drawn to another is moved by adoption to a family of that trade. The syphogrants' main charge is that no one stay idle or be worn out like a beast of burden. They work six hours, three before noon and three after, sleep eight, and the rest belongs to each person, provided it is not spent on luxury or softness; most give it to learning. Hythloday explains why six hours suffice: in other nations, nearly all the women, the multitude of priests, the rich with their retinues and the sturdy beggars live without producing, and many of those who do work are busy with empty arts. The aim of the republic is to give everyone the maximum free time for the mind. In Book II, Section 1 the farmers take turns between city and country so that no one is forced into a harsh life for long, and in Book II, Section 6 the traveler practices his trade wherever he is and does not eat before completing the morning's task.

The work of the island is short, universal and visible. Too visible, perhaps: in Book II, Section 6 there is no tavern, no meeting place and no hiding place, and the eyes of everyone compel customary work or honest leisure. It also has a side that the text does not hide: the dirtiest services in the hall and the slaughter of animals fall to the slaves (Book II, Section 5), and the choice of trade yields when the city needs another more. Vocation, for its part, has a place only for a few: the people choose, on the priests' advice, those who devote themselves to study full time, and it is from these scholars that the ambassadors, priests, tranibors and the prince come. Hythloday, who defends the island where no one is idle, refuses the office of counselor and says he lives as he pleases, and the book does not comment on it.

Where It Appears

  • Letter to Peter Giles: More's day, taken up by his profession, and the time stolen from sleep to write.
  • Book I, Section 1: Hythloday leaves his inheritance and prefers to wander rather than have a tomb, giving up gain in favor of curiosity about the world.
  • Book I, Section 2: The refusal to serve the king and the argument that knowledge should serve the public good.
  • Book I, Section 3: The idleness of nobles and servants, and the soldiers without a trade, as a cause of theft.
  • Book II, Section 1: The rotation of farmers between city and country spreads the work of the land among all, so that no one is tied to it.
  • Book II, Section 4: Each person's trade, the six hours, free time for learning and the calculation of why they suffice.
  • Book II, Section 5: The dirty services in the hall fall to the slaves, and so the most painful work does not fall on the free citizens at the common meals.
  • Book II, Section 6: Travel by permission, the trade practiced wherever one is and the eyes of everyone on each person.

Passages

Hythloday, more eager to wander than for a tomb.

So he was left, that his own mind might be obeyed, more eager to wander than for a tomb.
Book I, Section 1: The Traveler Raphael Hythloday

"For a syllable, rather than serve."

for a syllable, rather than serve
Book I, Section 2: Raphael's Travels

The rotation of the farmers.

This custom of renewing the farmers is the rule, so that no one is forced, against his will, to continue for long a harsher life.
Book II, Section 1: The Island of Utopia

Agriculture, the common art from which no one is exempt.

There is one art common to all, men and women without distinction: agriculture, from which no one is exempt.
Book II, Section 4: The Trades

The syphogrants' charge: neither idleness nor exhaustion.

The principal and almost sole charge of the syphogrants is to see and take care that no one sits idle, but that each devotes himself diligently to his art, without, however, being worn out like beasts of burden by continuous labor from daybreak until late at night.
Book II, Section 4: The Trades

The six hours of work.

For that is an affliction worse than slavery, and yet it is almost everywhere the life of artisans, except among the Utopians. They divide the day, counting the night, into twenty-four equal hours, and assign only six to work
Book II, Section 4: The Trades

Free time is left to each person's discretion.

Everything that lies between the hours of work and the interval for sleep and food is left to each person's discretion, not so that he may abuse it in luxury or softness, but so that, freed from his trade, he may employ it well in another occupation, according to his taste.
Book II, Section 4: The Trades

The idlers of other nations, who explain why six hours suffice.

Besides, how great and how idle is the throng of priests and so-called religious! Add all the rich, especially the landlords, whom the common people call gentlemen and nobles; add their retinue, all that scum of swaggering rogues.
Book II, Section 4: The Trades

The dirtiest services fall to the slaves.

In this hall, all the services involving a little more filth or labor are performed by slaves.
Book II, Section 5: The Citizens' Common Life

No pretext for idleness, and the eyes of everyone on each person.

You see, then, that there is nowhere any license for idling, no pretext for sloth, no wine tavern, no ale-house, nowhere a brothel, no occasion for corruption, no hiding place, no meeting spot; but, with the eyes of all fixed upon each person, there is imposed the necessity either of customary labor or of leisure that is not dishonorable.
Book II, Section 6: The Utopians' Travels