The Theme in the Work
The Prince treats violence as an instrument of government, with a cost and with calculation, and almost never in the abstract. From Chapter V, where the safest way with cities that lived free is to ruin them, the book measures violence by what it produces: the free city destroyed does not rebel, and the one not destroyed ends by destroying the conqueror. Chapter VI gives the first rule: armed prophets won and unarmed ones were ruined, because the people are fickle, and one must be so organized that, when they no longer believe, one can make them believe by force. Chapter VII brings the best-known scene: Cesare Borgia puts the cruel Ramiro d'Orco at the head of the Romagna, the region is pacified, and to clear away the hatred he has him cut in two pieces in the square at Cesena, with a block of wood and a bloody knife beside him, which leaves the people at once satisfied and stunned (The Execution in the Square at Cesena).
Chapter VIII gives the theory. Agathocles and Oliverotto of Fermo seize power by crime, one with the massacre of the Senate, the other with the banquet at which he kills his uncle and the guests, and the text does not discuss the merit of the two, but asks why Agathocles lived secure and so many others could not hold the state even in peace. The answer is that there are cruelties well used and badly used: those well used are committed all at once, out of the necessity of securing oneself, and are afterward converted into the benefit of the subjects; those badly used grow with time. Injuries should be done all together, so that they offend less, and benefits little by little, so that they may be savored more. The same chapter denies that this is virtù: it brings empire, and not glory. Chapter XVII applies the principle: Cesare's cruelty restored order to the Romagna, and the prince should make himself feared in such a way as to avoid hatred, respecting his subjects' property and women, because men forget the death of a father sooner than the loss of their patrimony. At the head of an army, one must not mind the name of cruel, like Hannibal, who without his inhuman cruelty would not have kept the army united.
Chapter XIX shows the practical limit: hatred is acquired as much by good deeds as by bad ones, and the Roman emperors killed by soldiers or by conspirators were those who made themselves hated or despised; among the cruel, only Severus, fox and lion, came to a good end. Chapter XX treats violence against one's own subjects, disarming them, as an offense that breeds hatred. Chapter XXI brings the "pious cruelty" of Ferdinand of Aragon, who, making use of Religion, expelled the Marranos from the kingdom.
The book does not recommend violence as such, it recommends the economy of it: once, out of necessity, without touching what men prize most, and always measured by the hatred it may breed. The text supports two readings of the judgment. In one, Machiavelli describes the effect and lets the reader decide, as in the dry account of Cesena. In the other, Chapter VIII judges: what is done by crime brings empire, and not glory. The two are in the same chapter, and the advice to commit cruelties all at once coexists with the statement that they do not give glory to those who commit them.
Where It Appears
- Chapter V: Ruining the city that lived free is the sure way of possessing it.
- Chapter VI: Armed prophets win and unarmed ones are ruined: one must be able to make people believe by force.
- Chapter VII: The death of Ramiro d'Orco in the square at Cesena and the ambush at Sinigaglia.
- Chapter VIII: Agathocles and Oliverotto, and the rule of cruelties well used and badly used.
- Chapter XVII: The cruelty that restores order to the Romagna, fear without hatred and the cruelty of the army captain.
- Chapter XIX: The hatred and contempt that kill princes, and Severus, fox and lion.
- Chapter XX: To disarm subjects is to offend them, and the best fortress is not to be hated.
- Chapter XXI: The pious cruelty of Ferdinand of Aragon, who expels the Marranos from the kingdom, is an example of violence that keeps subjects suspended and admiring.
Passages
In Chapter VI, the limit of persuasion.
And therefore one must be so organized that, when they no longer believe, one can make them believe by force.
In Chapter VII, the square at Cesena.
he had him placed one morning in two pieces, at Cesena, in the square, with a block of wood and a bloody knife beside him. The ferocity of that spectacle left those peoples at once satisfied and stunned.
In Chapter VIII, the difference between using well and badly.
Well used may be called those (if it is permitted to speak well of evil) that are committed all at once, out of the necessity of securing oneself, and are not afterward persisted in, but are converted into the greatest possible benefit for the subjects.
In the same chapter, what cruelty does not give.
Yet it cannot be called virtù to kill one's own citizens, betray friends, be without faith, without pity, without religion; these ways can win one empire, but not glory.
In Chapter XVII, the effect of a cruelty in the Romagna.
that cruelty of his had restored order to the Romagna, united it and brought it to peace and loyalty
In the same chapter, why fear is worth more.
love is held by a bond of obligation, which, because men are wicked, is broken at every occasion of their own advantage; but fear is held by a dread of punishment that never abandons you