Who He Is
Machiavelli is the voice that speaks on every page of The Prince: the author who addresses a prince in the first person, sometimes as an adviser, sometimes as a witness to what he has seen. In the Dedication he presents himself as a man of low condition who offers the one in command the only good he possesses, knowledge of the actions of great men, acquired through long experience of modern affairs and a continual reading of the ancient ones. The book never tells his life all at once. It only lets him appear in flashes: the envoy who stood before Cesare Borgia, the Florentine who argues with a French cardinal, the man who organized a militia, the secretary who knows what a minister does, the writer who takes his leave with verses of a poet. What he wants from the reader is that he read politics as it is practiced, and not as one would wish it to be, and that he use what he has read. Here what matters is the man the book itself shows, and the author outside the text has his page in Niccolò Machiavelli.
Trajectory
In the Dedication, he writes to Lorenzo de' Medici and begins with the custom of those who wish to win a prince's favor, which is to bring him what they hold dearest. He judges the work unworthy of the one who receives it, but he has not adorned the text: he wanted only the truth of the matter to make it pleasing. He foresees the charge of presumption, because a man of low condition dares to discourse on the governments of princes, and answers with the image of those who draw landscapes.
to know well the nature of peoples one must be a prince, and to know well that of princes one must be of the people
He closes the dedication by asking the prince to turn his eyes to the low places and see the malignity of fortune that he endures without deserving it: the master of power appears, in the last lines, as one who needs it.
In Chapter II, he sets aside the republics, of which he says he has already treated at length on another occasion, and turns only to the principality. In Chapter III, he enters the scene himself: he tells of the conversation he had at Nantes with the cardinal of Rouen, minister of the king of France, when Cesare Borgia was occupying the Romagna, and says that he told him the French did not understand the state. The reader sees him as one who observed the error close up and said so to the one committing it.
In Chapter VII, he is a witness. He quotes what Cesare told him in the days when Julius II was created, and the sentence exists only because he was there.
Machiavelli met Cesare Borgia in 1502, as Florence's envoy.
In Chapter XIV, the thesis that the prince should have no other art than war and its ordinances is that of one who has already tried to put it into practice.
Between 1505 and 1506, Machiavelli secured in Florence the creation of a militia of citizens and peasants, which he organized as secretary of the Republic. That militia was defeated by the Spaniards at Prato, in 1512, and the Republic fell with the return of the Medici.
In Chapter XV, he declares the method of the book. He knows that many have already written on the subject and fears seeming presumptuous in departing from them, but decides to follow the truth of things and not the imagination of them, because many have imagined republics and principalities that never existed.
it has seemed to me more fitting to go after the effectual truth of the matter than the imagination of it
In Chapter XVII, he speaks as a Florentine: he recalls that the people of Florence, to avoid the name of cruel, let Pistoia be destroyed. In Chapter XXII, the title names the secretaries, and the text turns to speak of ministers: there are three kinds of brains, the one that understands by itself, the one that understands what another shows it and the one that understands neither by itself nor by another's demonstration, and the minister who thinks more of himself than of the prince will never be good.
Machiavelli held the office of secretary in the Chancery of Florence from 1498 to 1512.
In Chapter XXV, he confesses that he partly inclines to the opinion of those who leave everything to fortune and to God, but, so that free will may not be extinguished, he judges that fortune may be the arbiter of half of our actions and leaves the government of the other half, or nearly so, to us. In Chapter XXVI, he stops analyzing and exhorts: he asks whether the times are running in Italy to honor a new prince, sees in the House of Medici the best hope and closes the book with four verses of Petrarch, a voice that is not his own.
Themes Embodied
Machiavelli passes through three themes of the work. He is Politics seen by one who observed it close up and now writes it for those who practice it. He is Knowledge and Wisdom, because what he has to give is a knowledge that came from experience and from the ancients, and that is what he offers in place of the usual gift. And he is Fate and Free Will in the personal form of fortune: she promises greatness to the prince and gives him only malignity, and in Chapter XXV he divides actions between her and us.
The text supports two readings of who is speaking. In one, he is an observer who teaches frankly what he has seen, and therefore refuses ornament and chooses the effectual truth. In the other, he is a man outside power who uses the book to be noticed by those who hold it: the final request of the Dedication and the exhortation of Chapter XXVI to a particular house show that the knowledge comes together with a need. The two fit, and one does not contradict the other, because what he knows is exactly what he offers.
Relationships
- Lorenzo de' Medici: the addressee, to whom he offers the book in the Dedication and whom he exhorts in Chapter XXVI.
- Cesare Borgia: the duke he met as an envoy and whose actions he recounts in Chapter VII as one who was present.
- Alexander VI: the pope he presents in Chapter XVIII as the deceiver whose deceptions always worked.
- Julius II: the impetuous pope he uses in Chapter XXV to show what fortune does for the man who hits on the right time.
- Louis XII: the king of France, whose minister, the cardinal of Rouen, hears from him in Chapter III that the French did not understand the state.
- Ferdinand of Aragon: the king of his time whom he chooses as a model of esteem in Chapter XXI.
- Francesco Sforza and Agathocles: the example of one who rises by virtù and that of one who rises by crime, which he sets side by side without confusing them.