Who He Is
Peter Giles is the friend from Antwerp: the addressee of the opening letter and the person who sets Thomas More before Raphael Hythloday. The book describes him as a learned young man, loyal and good company, who visits More often and eases his homesickness during the mission to Flanders. In the conversation that follows, he is the one who vouches for the traveler, who asks what a reader would ask and who doubts when it is fitting. What he wants is to bring together two people whom he believes will do each other good, and to see Hythloday employed in something useful. What he knows is people: he knows the traveler, he knows his friend and he knows what each can give the other. His role in the book is that of witness: the truth of the account passes through Peter's trust, and it is in him that the chain of secondhand words finds its first link.
Trajectory
In the Letter to Peter Giles, he is the man to whom More answers. More asks him to check whether the bridge at Amaurot is five hundred paces or three hundred, to find out in what part of the world the island lies and to question Hythloday, preferably by showing him the book. The task falls to Peter because he is the one who knows the traveler.
In Book I, Section 1, he introduces Hythloday to More: he corrects his friend, who had taken him for a ship's captain, and says that he sailed like Ulysses, or rather, like Plato. And he sells the traveler like someone announcing a rarity.
none of the mortals alive today could tell you such a story of men and of unknown lands.
In Book I, Section 2, amazed at what he hears, he asks why Hythloday does not join some king: with what he knows, he would please, instruct and counsel, and look after his own as well. When the traveler refuses to serve, he proposes a lighter phrase, to render service, and receives the reply that this is, by one syllable, more than serving.
for a syllable, rather than serve
In Book I, Section 4, when Hythloday says that Morus has not seen Utopia, he doubts that a people of the New World could be better ordered than those of Europe, and Hythloday answers that the Utopians learned from shipwrecked Romans and Egyptians and have more zeal. It is Peter, together with Morus, who asks for the description of the island, and the conversation continues after lunch.
Themes Embodied
Peter Giles carries friendship, which the book shows as conversation, visits and favors: he eases More's homesickness and also does what a friend does best, introducing someone worth listening to. He also carries Truth and Lies, because he is the guarantor of the account, and Politics, because his question in Book I, Section 2 is the one that opens the debate about serving or not serving kings.
Peter is the most discreet of the three in the conversation and the one who most moves the book along: he asks, introduces, doubts, asks for more. The text does not show what he thinks of himself, and almost nothing of what he thinks of Utopia. One reading sees in him an honest intermediary, who repeats well what he sees. Another notes that the proof of the account is only the word of a friend: the letter asks him to find out where the island lies, and the book ends without the answer.
Relationships
- Thomas More: the friend who visits him in Antwerp and to whom the letter is addressed.
- Raphael Hythloday: the traveler he introduces, whom he partly doubts and whom he asks why he does not serve a king.
- Cardinal Morton, the Lawyer, Utopus and the Utopians: the figures he knows only through what Hythloday tells, together with More.