The Theme in the Work
Pride is the diagnosis that Raphael Hythloday gives, in the end, for everything he criticizes. In Book II, Section 12 he says that the reason or the authority of Christ would already have led the world to the laws of the island, were it not for pride, which measures prosperity not by one's own advantages but by the disadvantages of others, and which is the mother of all plagues. In Book II, Section 5 the diagnosis has its economic form: what makes every kind of animal greedy and rapacious is the fear of lacking, and in man it is only pride, which finds glory in surpassing others by the display of the superfluous. That is why, where there is abundance of everything, no one would have a reason to take more than his share.
The book shows pride in four places. In the council of kings (Book I, Section 2), counselors act as if their fame for wisdom were at stake and take refuge in "This pleased our ancestors," and those who listen praise the absurdity of whoever is in the prince's favor. In war (Book II, Section 10), the Utopians find the glory sought in it inglorious and are ashamed of a bloody victory, as of merchandise bought too dear. In gold (Book II, Section 7), the Anemolian ambassadors adorn themselves to look like gods and are taken for slaves, and a boy's mother calls them fools. In the island's senate (Book II, Section 3), the rule of discussing nothing on the day it is proposed exists so that no one, out of a twisted shame, will prefer to sacrifice the public safety rather than the opinion others have of him.
There is also the taste and the ingratitude of readers, treated with humor in the letter. In the Letter to Peter Giles, More describes readers of delicate palate and of a "mind so mindful and grateful," like the guest who eats the banquet and does not give thanks, and says that he has not yet decided to publish. In Book I, Section 3, the lawyer who prepares to answer in the manner of the schools and the friar who takes offense at the jester show at the table what Hythloday describes in the council. And in Book II, Section 12, when the narrator falls silent, one of the reasons is that Raphael had criticized those who want to seem wise by nibbling at the inventions of others.
The book presents pride as the root of more than one evil, and not only of the rich. Greed, display, the glory of war and the shame of backing down all come from the same will to be more than the other, and that is why the institutions of the island exist to disarm it: gold goes into the chamber pot, discussion waits for the next day, the glory of a bloody victory is shame. But the text leaves open a reading that Hythloday does not make. Someone who accuses the pride of others, refuses to serve the king and has an answer for everything may seem proud himself, and the narrator, who falls silent, does not say whether he thinks so. The book shows a man convinced that he has seen the better republic and an author who, in the end, does not agree to everything.
Where It Appears
- Letter to Peter Giles: More and the readers of delicate palate and a mind "so mindful and grateful," and the guest who does not thank his host.
- Book I, Section 2: The counselors who defend their own fame for wisdom with "This pleased our ancestors."
- Book I, Section 3: The lawyer who prepares to answer in the manner of the schools, and the friar who takes offense at the jester.
- Book II, Section 3: The twisted shame of one who prefers to lose the public safety rather than the opinion others have of him.
- Book II, Section 5: Pride as what makes man greedy, in place of the fear of lacking.
- Book II, Section 7: The ambassadors who want to look like gods, the laughter of the children and the gold of the chamber pots.
- Book II, Section 10: The glory sought in war as an inglorious thing, and the shame of a bloody victory.
- Book II, Section 12: The pride that measures prosperity by the misery of others, and More's silence.
Passages
The holy ambition, the one born of piety and not of the calculation of honor.
For he considers holy the ambition that is born not from the calculation of honor or profit, but from the consideration of piety
The ancestors, whose prudence we would that we equaled.
This pleased our ancestors, whose prudence we would that we equaled
The twisted and perverse shame of those who defend what they said without thinking.
And so, out of a twisted and perverse shame, he would sooner sacrifice the public safety than the opinion others have of him, so as not to seem to have foreseen too little at the start. Yet it was his duty to foresee from the start, to speak with reflection and not in haste.
What makes man greedy is pride, not fear.
What makes every kind of animal greedy and rapacious is the fear of lacking; in man, it is only pride, which counts it glory to surpass others by the display of the superfluous.
The mother sees the ambassador of pearls as a fool.
Look, mother, what a great rogue, he still wears pearls and little gems, as if he were a little boy!
The glory sought in war is not glory.
War, as a thoroughly bestial thing, and yet one that no kind of beast practices as assiduously as man, they abominate to the extreme. And, contrary to the custom of almost all peoples, they consider nothing so inglorious as the glory sought in war.
A bloody victory is shame, not glory.
For a bloody victory they not only grieve but are ashamed, counting it ignorance to have bought any merchandise too dear, however precious it may be.
Pride measures prosperity by the disadvantage of others.
This measures prosperity not by its own advantages, but by the disadvantages of others.