Who He Is
Utopus is the founder of the island: the conqueror who gave it its name and its shape. He does not speak in any scene of the book. He exists only in what Raphael Hythloday attributes to him, and everything attributed to him is decisions: cutting the isthmus, laying out the city, fixing religious tolerance. The island was called Abraxa before him, and the land was not always an island. The book presents him as a victor who brought a rude and rustic mob to a degree of culture at which it now surpasses almost all other mortals. What he wants, judging by his acts, is an isolated land, an order that repeats from city to city and a peace in which no one has to kill over religion. What he knows, and the text takes care to show, is that a single life is not enough to finish a work, and that is why he leaves the finishing to posterity.
The name Utopia comes from the Greek ou-topos, "no place."
Trajectory
In Book II, Section 1, he lands, wins and brings the people to a high degree of culture. Then he has fifteen miles dug at the point where the land joined the continent and makes the sea flow around it.
But Utopus, from whose name, as victor, the island takes its name (for before that time it was called Abraxa), was the one who brought a rude and rustic mob to that degree of culture and humanity in which it now surpasses almost all other mortals.
He sets the inhabitants to digging, and his soldiers too, so that no one would take the labor as an insult. When the canal is finished, the neighbors, who had laughed at the idea, are amazed and afraid.
For this work he forced not only the inhabitants (so that they would not take the labor as an insult), but joined to them all his soldiers.
In Book II, Section 2, he lays out the whole figure of Amaurot but leaves the ornament and the finishing to posterity, because they would not fit in a single life. The annals, says Hythloday, cover one thousand seven hundred and sixty years since the conquest, and the houses, which began as huts, are now three stories high.
In Book II, Section 11, he is the origin of tolerance. The earlier inhabitants fought over religion, and he establishes that each person may follow the one he wishes and try to persuade the others only with reasons, without violence or insult. He judges that peace and religion itself gain if the question is left open, and forbids only the thought that the soul dies with the body or that the world goes by chance.
But to demand by force and threats that what you believe true should seem so to everyone, this he judged insolent and foolish.
Themes Embodied
Utopus carries Politics as the work of a founder: the island is born of an act of force and of a plan. He carries Religion through the rule of tolerance, and Work and Vocation through the canal dug by victors and vanquished, which is the island's first lesson about work.
Hythloday says without embarrassment that the creator of the best state was a warrior who won, and the reader of the time would have expected a sage. The text does not comment on the tension between the conquest and the "humanity" that follows. Two readings fit. In one, he is a prudent founder who knows that order must be designed from above and handed over to time. In the other, he is a conqueror who first isolates the people from the world and only then teaches them to live, and what that solitude costs the island Hythloday does not say.
Relationships
- Raphael Hythloday: the one who tells everything that is known of him and speaks of his work in a tone of praise.
- The Utopians: the people he leads from rude to cultured, who dig the canal beside his soldiers and inherit the tolerance.
- Thomas More and Peter Giles: the listeners of the account, who know him only through what Hythloday attributes to him.