Clavis Libri

Questions · The Prince

What does Machiavelli say about fortune?

The answer is in chapter XXV. Machiavelli acknowledges that many believe the things of the world are governed by fortune and by God, so that the prudence of men does not correct them. He inclines in part to this opinion, but, "so that our free will may not be extinguished," he judges that "fortune is the arbiter of half of our actions, but that she leaves the government of the other half, or almost, to us."

To show how she is resisted, he uses an image: fortune is like a ruinous river which, when it becomes enraged, floods the plains and tears down trees and buildings. But, in calm times, men can build embankments and dikes, so that the flood afterward runs through a channel or is not so harmful. Italy, he says, is a field without dikes and without any embankment. That is why fortune shows her power where there is no organized virtue to resist her.

The chapter adds that success depends on the meeting of one's way of acting with the quality of the times: "happy is he whose way of proceeding accords with the quality of the times." Pope Julius II, who acted with impetuosity, prospered because the times were in accord with him. Chapter XXIV had already told the Italian princes not to accuse fortune, "but their own sloth." Fortune, in the book, is a real power, but never an excuse.

More questions about The Prince

See all questions