Clavis Libri

Questions · The Prince

Did Machiavelli say that the ends justify the means?

No. The phrase "the ends justify the means" does not appear in The Prince, and it summarizes poorly what Machiavelli writes. The closest passage is in chapter XVIII, and says the following: "in the actions of all men, and above all of princes, where there is no tribunal to appeal to, one looks to the end. Let the prince, then, take care to live and to keep the State: the means will always be judged honorable and praised by all."

The difference lies in the verb. Machiavelli does not claim that the end makes the means good; he claims that the means "will always be judged" honorable. It is an observation about how men evaluate power: since there is no tribunal above the prince, the people look at the result, and whoever keeps the State is praised. The chapter says shortly afterward that "the common people are always taken by what seems and by the outcome of the thing." Describing how one is judged is not the same as saying the judgment is right.

The book also sets limits. In chapter VIII, on Agathocles, he writes: "Yet it cannot be called virtue to kill one's fellow citizens, betray friends, be without faith, without pity, without religion; these ways may win empire, but not glory." And again in chapter XVIII he asks the prince for a mind disposed "not to depart from the good, if he can, but to know how to enter into evil, if forced." This is not indifference to the means. Even so, the advice is hard: the prince must think of keeping the State, and necessity may compel him to what is not good. The reader may disagree with him, but the text does not say the phrase that is attributed to it.

More questions about The Prince

See all questions