Clavis Libri

Questions · The Prince

Did Machiavelli defend cruelty?

The book treats cruelty as an instrument, not as a value, and sets conditions. In chapter VIII, Machiavelli says that cruelties can be well or badly used. Those well used, “if it is permitted to speak well of evil,” are those done all at once, out of the necessity of securing oneself, and then not persisted in, but converted into the greatest possible benefit for the subjects. Those badly used are the ones that, few at the beginning, grow with time.

In chapter XVII, he says that the prince should wish to be held merciful and not cruel, but should take care not to misuse clemency. He affirms that Borgia, who was held cruel, reordered the Romagna, uniting it and bringing it to peace and loyalty, and that the prince should not mind the name of cruel when he commands an army. But he asks that he abstain from the property and the women of his subjects, and shed blood only with proper justification and manifest cause.

The same book affirms, in chapter VIII, that killing one's fellow citizens and betraying friends cannot be called virtue and gives empire, but not glory. The most faithful reading is that Machiavelli describes what violence produces, tells what it costs and says when it is necessary, without presenting it as a good. Whoever reads the book may judge the advice as he wishes, but the text does not make cruelty an end in itself.

More questions about The Prince

See all questions