The criticism fills chapters XII and XIII. Machiavelli says that the principal foundations of all States are good laws and good arms, and that mercenary and auxiliary arms are useless and dangerous. Whoever founds his State on mercenaries never stands firm, because they are “disunited, ambitious, without discipline, unfaithful; brave among friends, vile among enemies.” They have no other love nor any other reason to keep them in the field than a little pay, “which is not enough to make them want to die for you.”
Mercenary captains create a second problem. If they are excellent, they cannot be trusted, because they aspire to their own greatness; if they are not, they ruin whoever hired them. That is why, he says, these arms produce only “slow, late and weak conquests, and sudden and miraculous losses.” The proof he gives is the French invasion of Italy, in which Charles was able to take it, in the author's phrase, “with chalk.”
Auxiliary arms, those of a powerful man one calls in to help, are even more dangerous: “if you lose, you are undone; if you win, you are their prisoner” (chapter XIII). The way out is to have arms of one's own, made up of subjects, citizens or servants of the prince. Machiavelli concludes that “without arms of one's own no principality is secure,” and that is why, in the last chapter, he asks the prince to provide himself with arms of his own as the true foundation of every enterprise.