Clavis Libri

Symbol

The Gold of the Chamber Pots

What It Is

The gold of the chamber pots is the Utopians' decision to give gold and silver the vilest use the island knows. Raphael Hythloday tells that, while they eat and drink from earthenware and glass, elegant and cheap, they make of gold and silver the chamber pots and the most squalid vessels, in the common halls and in private houses. The chains and fetters of the slaves are made of the same metals, and whoever has committed a disgraceful crime wears rings, a necklace and a crown of gold. It is a symbol because the most fought-over object in Europe appears in the lowest place, and the reader reads in this exchange what the book thinks of value.

Where It Appears

The image occupies Book II, Section 7. The Utopians bring in gold and silver from trade and keep them as a war treasure. So that no one will become attached to them, they use them in the vilest way.

For while they eat and drink from earthenware and glass, elegant indeed but cheap, they make chamber pots out of gold and silver everywhere, and every kind of the most squalid vessel, not only in the common halls but also in private houses.
Book II, Section 7: Shared Abundance and the Scorn of Gold

The method is dishonor: gold comes to mark the infamous, and the honor that is given to it is undone by association with shame.

Thus they take care, by every means, that among them gold and silver be held in ignominy.
Book II, Section 7: Shared Abundance and the Scorn of Gold

The reason for the use comes in the same section: to gold and silver nature assigned no use that cannot be done without, and the price comes from rarity and from the folly of men.

to gold and silver nature assigned no use that we cannot easily do without, had not the folly of men put a price on rarity.
Book II, Section 7: Shared Abundance and the Scorn of Gold

The treasure returns in Book II, Section 10: it is with it that the Utopians pay foreign soldiers and buy enemies, and they spend it without reluctance, because they would live equally well without it. In Book II, Section 12, Hythloday closes the idea: money was invented to open the way to sustenance and it is only money that closes it. Earlier, in Book I, Section 4, he had already said that where everything is measured by money, the republic is not well governed.

What It Means

The gold of the chamber pots means that the value of things is a convention, and that the island has chosen another. What is worth something is what serves: iron, indispensable like fire and water, is almost the only thing they import, and gold, which can be done without effortlessly, is worth only for its rarity. The text does not condemn the metal, it condemns the esteem that is given to it, and gives gold the place that undoes it as a motive for greed.

The symbol also has a practical use, which Hythloday presents as the solution to a problem and not as an extravagance. If the gold were locked in a tower, the people would suspect that the prince and the senate were diverting it, and if it were made into cups, it would be hard to take them from the hands of those who held them for delight when war required the metal.

The image makes one laugh and makes one think, and the book leaves the two things together. The scorn for gold is a planned institution, not a trait of character: the text does not say that the Utopians are virtuous on that account, but that they chose a means of not having the problem of greed. As for the cost, the text does not say, and the scorned gold continues to be kept and spent to buy the war of others.

Relationships