Who He Is
Alexander VI is the pope the book shows from three sides that Machiavelli does not reconcile. He is the father of Cesare Borgia, whom he could enlarge only by throwing Italy into disorder. He is the pope who, wanting to enlarge his son, enlarged the Church without meaning to, showing how much a pope could prevail with money and with arms. And he is the recent example of the fortunate deceiver: he never did anything but deceive, he swore as no one else and kept his word less, and his deceptions always worked. What he wants, from beginning to end, is a state for his son. What he knows is that men are simple and live by the needs of the moment, and for that reason let themselves be deceived. Machiavelli cites him without condemning him, because his interest is in what Alexander's method produced.
Alexander VI (Rodrigo Borgia) was pope from 1492 to 1503 and died in August 1503.
Trajectory
In Chapter III, the pope appears as the beneficiary of another's error: the king of France helped him occupy the Romagna, enlarging the Church and losing his friends. In Chapter VII, he is the father who prepares his son's fortune. To enlarge him, he had to throw Italy into disorder, and he made the coming of the king of France easier by dissolving the marriage of Louis XII. His death leaves Cesare ill between two hostile armies, and it is fortune that takes from him what she herself had given.
In Chapter XI, the chapter asks where the Church's temporal greatness came from, which before Alexander almost no one esteemed, and answers with the political history of the popes: it was he who showed what a pope could do with money and arms, by means of the Duke Valentino and the coming of the French.
showed how much a pope could prevail, with money and with arms
Intention and result come apart. Alexander's intent was to enlarge the duke, and still what he did redounded to the greatness of the Church.
And although his intent was not to enlarge the Church, but the duke, still what he did redounded to the greatness of the Church
In Chapter XVIII, he is the example of how the fox is used. Machiavelli gives him the greatest efficacy in swearing and the least in keeping his word, and concludes that men are so simple that whoever deceives will always find someone willing to be deceived.
whoever deceives will always find someone willing to be deceived
Themes Embodied
Alexander embodies Power placed at the service of a family, and Chapter XI says so clearly: the intent was the duke, not the Church. He also embodies Truth and Lies, because Chapter XVIII chooses him as the case of one who made the broken promise a method that worked. And he is the family as a political engine, the father who uses the Church to enlarge his son and leaves the result to an institution that was not the target.
The book gives two images of him, and both are true at once. In one, the pope who makes the Church great, with finances and arms and with the power of the barons of Rome beaten down. In the other, the deceiver who swears with no intention of keeping his word. Machiavelli does not say whether this was vice or calculation, and that is the force of the example: the reader of the time would expect a condemnation and hears that his deceptions always worked. What the text maintains is that Alexander knew this part of the world well, that of simple men, and that his efficacy came from that.
Relationships
- Cesare Borgia: the son, whom he could enlarge only by throwing Italy into disorder and who lost the state with his father's death.
- Louis XII: the king whose marriage he dissolved, which made the coming of the French easier, and who helped him occupy the Romagna.
- Julius II: the pope who came after and found the Church great, the barons of Rome beaten down by Alexander's blows and the road of money opened.
- Machiavelli: the author who presents him as a master of deception, without passing judgment.