Who He Is
Louis XII, king of France, is the book's counter-model: the real and recent king who, by doing the opposite of what the Romans did, took Lombardy and lost it. Chapter III places him before the reader as the proof that conquering and holding are different things, and that the second is lost through carelessness. What he wants is to win in Italy. What he does not know, or does not want to know, is that whoever makes another powerful ruins himself. What Machiavelli says of him is that he does not blame him for going to Italy, because it is natural to desire to conquer, but for wanting to without being able, and he counts five errors against him, plus a sixth, that of ruining the Venetians. He is, therefore, a king whom the book uses as a lesson in method, and not as a villain.
Louis XII (1462-1515) entered Milan in 1499; Ludovico Sforza, the Moor, duke until then, returned in 1500 and was defeated that same year; the French lost Milan for good only in 1512, driven out of Italy.
Trajectory
In Chapter III, he is the character of the chapter. He took Milan at once and at once lost it: the forces of Ludovico Sforza were enough to take it from him the first time, and the second time it took having the whole world against him and seeing the French armies driven out of Italy. Machiavelli compares him to the Romans, who sent colonies, kept the Achaeans and the Aetolians without giving them more power, brought down the Macedonians and saw evils from afar, like the physician who treats the hectic fever at the start. Louis did the opposite: brought into Italy by the ambition of the Venetians, he won Lombardy and the friendship of almost all the lords of the peninsula, and then helped Pope Alexander VI occupy the Romagna, enlarging the Church and losing his friends, and divided Naples with the king of Spain instead of taking it alone.
It is a truly very natural and ordinary thing to desire to conquer, and always, when men do so being able, they will be praised and not censured; but when they cannot and want to do it at all costs, here lies the censure and the error
The rule Machiavelli draws from the errors is that whoever is the cause of another becoming powerful is ruined, because that power is brought about by him either with skill or with force, and both are suspect to the one who has become powerful.
whoever is the cause of another becoming powerful is ruined; because that power is brought about by him either with skill or with force, and both of these are suspect to the one who has become powerful
In Chapter VII, his name enters through the door of Cesare's father: Alexander VI made the coming of the king of France easier by dissolving the marriage of Louis XII. In Chapter XX, his French troops defeat Venice at Vailà, and in Chapter XXV, in the enterprise against Bologna, the pope drags the king behind him because he could not deny him troops without injuring him.
Louis XII and Ferdinand of Aragon divided Naples in an agreement of 1500 and soon quarreled over the partition; in 1503 the French were defeated and the kingdom went to Spain. Vailà is the battle of Agnadello, of May 14, 1509, in which the French troops of Louis XII defeated the army of Venice.
Themes Embodied
Louis XII embodies Politics as a calculation of who can and who cannot, and Chapter III says so by a yardstick that removes moral censure and replaces it with another: the error lies in wanting without being able. He also embodies Power seen from the side of the one who loses it, the king who conquered quickly and lost quickly. And he touches War, because the Italy he enters is that of foreign armies, and because Machiavelli himself uses his war to show the rule: war is not eliminated, it is postponed to the advantage of others.
The book gives two images of the king, and the second clarifies the first. On the surface, he is the careless one who breaks all the Roman rules and pays. Underneath, he is the man whose ambition to conquer the text does not deny, only his lack of proportionate means, and the contrast with the Romans shows that the cause of the defeat is one of method. Machiavelli sets himself up as one who saw this close up, in the conversation at Nantes, and the king remains, for that reason, more an example of management than of character.
Relationships
- Alexander VI: the pope he helped occupy the Romagna, enlarging the Church, and whose son used his troops.
- Cesare Borgia: the duke who entered the Romagna with French troops and afterward passed to other arms.
- Ferdinand of Aragon: the king with whom he divided Naples in 1500 and who kept the kingdom when the French were defeated, in 1503.
- Julius II: the pope who drags him behind him in the enterprise against Bologna and whom he afterward fights, in Chapter XVI, without levying an extraordinary tax.
- Machiavelli: the interlocutor who told the king's minister, at Nantes, that the French did not understand the state.