Clavis Libri

Character

Cesare Borgia

Who He Is

Cesare Borgia, Duke Valentino, is the most cited example in The Prince: the son of a pope who conquered a state with his father's fortune and with others' arms, did everything a prudent man should to put down roots and lost the state when fortune failed him. Chapter VII places him beside Francesco Sforza, who rose by virtù, and proposes him for imitation by one who rises by fortune and others' arms. What he wants is a state of his own in the Romagna. What he knows is how to buy those who can be bought, deceive those around him, eliminate those who threaten him and use the hatred of a minister to clear his own. What he did not foresee was that his own illness would coincide with his father's death. Machiavelli does not censure him and points out to him only one wrong choice.

Cesare Borgia (1475-1507), son of Pope Alexander VI, was duke of Valentinois and was therefore called Valentino. Machiavelli met him in 1502, as Florence's envoy.

Trajectory

In Chapter III, he appears from outside, in the middle of a conversation: when Machiavelli speaks at Nantes with the cardinal of Rouen, Cesare Borgia, Valentino, was occupying the Romagna. The chapter shows the king of France helping Pope Alexander occupy the region, which enlarged the Church and cost the king his friends.

In Chapter VII, he occupies the center. His father could enlarge him only by throwing Italy into disorder. With the Romagna conquered, Cesare saw that the arms of the Orsini were not faithful and that France would not let him advance, and decided to depend no longer on others' arms: he bought the nobles who were partisans of the Orsini and the Colonna, scattered the Colonna and deceived the Orsini with courtesies and gifts until he led them to Sinigaglia, where he eliminated them. He put the minister Ramiro d'Orco, cruel and efficient, at the head of the Romagna, and afterward, to escape the hatred, had him cut in two pieces in the square at Cesena. He had four defenses against a hostile pope and, at his father's death, three were in place and the fourth nearly so. But Alexander died, he fell ill, and the Romagna waited for him for more than a month.

Sinigaglia (today Senigallia): on December 31, 1502, Cesare Borgia seized there the leaders of the Orsini and the Vitelli, who had gathered against him, and had Vitellozzo Vitelli and Oliverotto of Fermo strangled.

he told me, in the days when Julius II was created, that he had thought of everything that might arise from his father's death and had found a remedy for all of it, except that he never thought that, at the hour of that death, he himself would also be close to death
Chapter VII: New Principalities Won with Others' Arms and Fortune

The error that Machiavelli points out to him is only one: at the election of Julius II, he should have blocked the cardinals he had offended.

And whoever believes that among great personages new benefits make them forget old injuries deceives himself.
Chapter VII: New Principalities Won with Others' Arms and Fortune

In Chapter VIII, he appears as the one who put an end to Oliverotto of Fermo: the traitor who had made himself prince of Fermo fell only because he let himself be deceived by Cesare at Sinigaglia. In Chapter XI, Alexander's intent was to enlarge the duke, and the result went to the Church. In Chapter XIII, he is the example of one who passes from auxiliary arms to his own: he entered the Romagna with French troops, took Imola and Forlì, passed to the mercenaries of the Orsini and the Vitelli, found them doubtful, eliminated them and kept his own, and his reputation rose at every step.

In Chapter XVII, the book recalls that he was held to be cruel and that this cruelty restored order to the Romagna, united and brought to peace and loyalty.

that cruelty of his had restored order to the Romagna, united it and brought it to peace and loyalty
Chapter XVII: Of Cruelty and Clemency, and Whether It Is Better to Be Loved or Feared

In Chapter XX, the name returns from the side: it was he who expelled Guidobaldo, duke of Urbino, and attacked Forlì, where the countess saw the people, her enemy, join the foreigner.

Themes Embodied

Cesare is Power conquered by one who did not have it, and therefore illustrates the book's question: what does a new prince do to stay. He is Violence as a measured instrument, used all at once and attributed to another, as in the case of Ramiro. And he is Fate and Free Will put to the test: he did everything that depended on him and was brought down by the one thing that did not.

The book offers two readings of him. In one, he is a model of method: the man who, in a few years, tries to do quickly what the founder does slowly, to have his own troops, win the people, eliminate those who can offend him. In the other, he is a loser, and the book does not hide how it ended. Machiavelli says he would not know how to censure him and attributes the fall to fortune and to a single error, and the two things lie side by side: fortune and decision working together. The lesson, for him, lies in the manner of acting and not in the result.

Relationships

  • Alexander VI: the father, whose fortune gives him the state and whose death loses it, and whose intent, says Chapter XI, was to enlarge his son.
  • Francesco Sforza: the contrast of Chapter VII, the man who rose by virtù and held with little effort what he had won with a thousand afflictions.
  • Julius II: the cardinal he should have kept from being elected pope, the only error the book points out to him.
  • Louis XII: the king whose marriage his father dissolved and whose troops he used as auxiliaries on entering the Romagna.
  • Agathocles: the ancient of Chapter VIII, which treats him and Oliverotto, whom Cesare killed at Sinigaglia, as cases of those who rise by crime.