Clavis Libri

Character

Ferdinand of Aragon

Who He Is

Ferdinand of Aragon, the king of Spain, is the model of esteem that the book gives to a prince of the reader's own time: the one who, from a weak king, became the first king of the Christians through great enterprises linked one to another. Machiavelli chooses him in Chapter XXI, and before that meets him in passing in several chapters, as the king who came to hold Naples, the ally of Julius II and the thrifty one who could make so many wars. What he wants is greatness, and what he knows is not to give his subjects time to act against him: each work is born of the previous one. What Machiavelli says of him is that there can be no more admirable or rarer example than the pious cruelty with which he expelled the Marranos from the kingdom.

Ferdinand II of Aragon (1452-1516) had reigned in Aragon since 1479 and, married to Isabella, in Castile.

Trajectory

In Chapter I, he appears in passing: the Kingdom of Naples is the example of a member added to the hereditary state of the king of Spain.

either they are entirely new, as Milan was for Francesco Sforza, or they are like members added to the hereditary state of the prince who acquires them, as the Kingdom of Naples is for the king of Spain
Chapter I: How Many Kinds of Principalities There Are and How They Are Acquired

The Kingdom of Naples passed to Ferdinand of Aragon, the king of Spain, in 1504.

In Chapter III, he divides Naples with Louis XII and, by the chapter's reading, becomes the companion whom the king of France places in Italy, to whom the discontented can turn. In Chapter XIII, he is the ally whom Julius II calls in after the trial of the mercenaries at Ferrara. In Chapter XVI, he is the king who, had he been held liberal, would not have made or won so many enterprises.

In Chapter XVIII, the text closes with a prince of the present day whom it is not fitting to name, who preaches nothing but peace and good faith and who, had he kept either, would have lost his state and his reputation more than once. The book does not name him, and the reading tradition sees Ferdinand in that prince.

In Chapter XXI, he is the model. He assailed Granada at the beginning of his reign and made it the foundation of his state: an unhurried war, which kept the barons of Castile occupied, who, thinking of it, did not think of innovating. He sustained his armies with money from the Church and from the peoples. Then, making use of Religion, he turned to a pious cruelty, expelling the Marranos from the kingdom.

he turned to a pious cruelty, expelling and despoiling his kingdom of the Marranos; and there can be no more admirable or rarer example
Chapter XXI: What a Prince Should Do to Be Esteemed

He attacked Africa, made the enterprise of Italy, attacked France. Each work was born of the previous one and never gave men room to settle down and act against him.

never gave men room to settle down and act against him
Chapter XXI: What a Prince Should Do to Be Esteemed

Granada, the last Muslim kingdom of the Iberian Peninsula, fell on January 2, 1492, after a war begun in 1482. In March 1492, Ferdinand and Isabella decreed the expulsion of the Jews who would not accept conversion.

Themes Embodied

Ferdinand embodies Power maintained by reputation: a king who, because he started out weak, needed fame and built it through an accumulation of enterprises. He embodies religion, but in the form that Chapter XXI describes, Religion used as a cloak under which Africa is attacked and the Marranos are expelled, and the book records this use without saying whether it approves. And he touches Appearance and Reality, because the prince of Chapter XVIII who preaches peace and faith and does not keep them, if it is he, is the living example that men judge by the eyes and not by the hands.

The text supports two readings. In one, Ferdinand is the esteemed king, the model for one who wants reputation, and Chapter XXI sets him up as such by the facts. In the other, he is the possible deceiver of Chapter XVIII, whom the book never names. The two support each other: esteem comes from great enterprises, and great enterprises, with Religion as a cloak, look like piety to those who receive them. Machiavelli describes the effect on those who look, the amazement and the admiration, and not the moral value of what was done, and the reader decides what to think.

Relationships

  • Louis XII: the king with whom he divided Naples in Chapter III and from whom he took the kingdom in 1503.
  • Alexander VI: the pope used, in Chapter XVIII, as the example of the fortunate deceiver, alongside the unnamed prince whom the traditional reading identifies with Ferdinand.
  • Francesco Sforza: the other example of Chapter I, that of Milan entirely new, set against Naples added to what the king already had.