Clavis Libri

Symbol

David's Armor

What It Is

David's armor is the image with which Machiavelli says that another man's weapon does not serve the one who wears it: in the biblical episode, Saul dresses David in his armor, David cannot walk in it and takes it off to face Goliath with the sling. The book brings it into Chapter XIII as a figure of arms of one's own, those a prince must have so as not to be left to fortune, and sums it up in one sentence: the arms of others either fall off your back, or weigh you down, or bind you.

1 Samuel 17 (in the book of 1 Samuel), verses 38 to 40: Saul dresses David in his armor and David, who is not used to it, says he cannot walk in it and takes it off. In the biblical account he takes the staff, the sling and five stones; the knife is Machiavelli's.

Where It Appears

The image is in Chapter XIII, the chapter on auxiliary, mixed and own arms. Machiavelli has just shown that auxiliaries, those of a powerful man called in to help, are always harmful to the one who calls them: if you lose, you are undone; if you win, you are their prisoner. He then cites the Old Testament, in which David refuses Saul's armor and goes to Goliath with the sling and the knife.

In short, the arms of others either fall off your back, or weigh you down, or bind you.
Chapter XIII: Auxiliary, Mixed and Own Soldiers

The same chapter concludes that without arms of one's own no principality is secure, and that one's own arms are those composed of subjects, citizens or servants of the prince. The idea returns in Chapter XXVI, the last chapter, when Machiavelli says that the true foundation of every enterprise is to provide oneself with arms of one's own.

as the true foundation of every enterprise, to provide oneself with arms of one's own; because one cannot have more faithful, truer or better soldiers
Chapter XXVI: Exhortation to Free Italy from the Barbarians

The idea was already in Chapter VI, in other clothes: armed prophets won and unarmed ones were ruined. The symbol of David gives that idea its most concrete body, that of the man who wins with what he knows how to wield.

What It Means

David's armor means that a prince's strength must fit him. The lesson of the scene, as Machiavelli reads it, is one of fit and not of courage: David wins because he fights with the weapon he knows, and the king's armor, which would be the best in the world, keeps him from walking. Thus, the security of a state lies not in the one who helps it, but in the one who defends it on his own account, and, as Chapter XII says of the armed people, whoever hands arms to others hands over liberty along with them.

The text supports two readings. In one, the image is a military argument: borrowed or paid troops are another man's armor, and only one's own serve. In the other, it is an argument about who the prince is: one's own arm is the one he himself has formed, and that is why the book speaks of a new ordering of the infantry in the final chapter, what is invented and gives reputation. The two readings join in that the choice of arms is a choice about who one is.

Relationships

  • Standard themes: War, Power, Virtù.
  • Characters: Cesare Borgia, who passes from auxiliary and mercenary arms to his own in Chapter XIII, and Julius II, who failed to reap the fruit of auxiliaries only because fortune gave him a third cause, the Swiss.
  • Neighboring symbols: the river of fortune, because without arms of one's own a principality is left wholly to fortune.