Who He Is
Julius II is the pope of impetuosity: the man who, in Chapter XXV, serves Machiavelli to show that fortune favors the one who proceeds in accordance with the quality of the times. Before that, the book meets him from many sides. He is the pope who attacks Ferrara, the one who allies himself with the king of Spain and sees the fruit of that bad choice saved by luck, the one who uses the name of liberal to reach the papacy and then drops it to make war, and the cardinal whom Cesare Borgia should have prevented from being elected. What he wants is to enlarge the Church, and not himself or a relative. What he knows is how to act quickly, before the others organize. What Machiavelli says of him, with cold irony, is that the brevity of his life spared him from seeing the times change.
Julius II (Giuliano della Rovere, 1443-1513) was pope from 1503 to 1513.
Trajectory
In Chapter II, he is the one who attacked Ferrara in 1510 and was resisted by the duke, whom the book cites as proof that an ancient dominion is held with little effort.
The duke of Ferrara, who withstood the assaults of the Venetians in '84 and those of Pope Julius in '10 for no other reason than being long established in that dominion
In Chapter VII, he appears as the cardinal whom Cesare should have prevented from being elected: at the death of Alexander VI, whoever believes that new benefits make great personages forget old injuries deceives himself, and that is what happened with the cardinal he had offended.
The cardinal called San Pietro ad Vincula was Giuliano della Rovere, elected pope in November 1503, with the name Julius II, after the brief pontificate of Pius III.
In Chapter XI, he finds the Church great, the barons of Rome beaten down and the road of money opened, and goes further: he wins Bologna, brings down the Venetians, drives out the French and keeps the Orsini and Colonna quiet, with no cardinals to stir them up. The text says that everything worked out for him, with so much the more praise for him because he did everything to enlarge the Church and not some private person.
In Chapter XIII, he is the recent example of auxiliary arms: after seeing, in the Ferrara enterprise, the sad proof of his mercenaries, he allied himself with Ferdinand of Aragon, king of Spain, and failed to reap the fruit of that bad choice only because fortune gave him a third cause, the Swiss, who drove out the victors after the defeat of the auxiliaries at Ravenna. In Chapter XVI, he used the name of liberal to reach the papacy and then dropped it, in order to make war on the king of France without an extraordinary tax, paying with the thrift of years.
In Chapter XXV, he is the central example. He always proceeded with impetuosity and found the times in accord. In the enterprise against Bologna, Venice did not approve of it and the king of Spain was negotiating with France; Julius moved in person, left Spain and Venice in suspense and dragged the king of France behind him, who could not deny him troops without injuring him.
for, if he changed his nature with the times and with circumstances, fortune would not change
Themes Embodied
Julius II embodies Fate and Free Will in the form of the relation between way of acting and age: he was fortunate because the times asked for his impetuosity, and Chapter XXV makes clear that, had they asked for caution, his ruin would have followed. He embodies War, because he is the pope who wins Bologna, brings down the Venetians and drives out the French. And he is Power placed at the service of an institution and not of a family, in contrast to Alexander VI.
The book uses the same man for two lessons. In Chapter XIII, he is the example of one who errs in the choice of arms and is saved by luck. In Chapter XXV, he is the example of one who hits on the time by nature and is rewarded by fortune. The two lessons are read together: the same pope who escapes by chance from the auxiliaries is the one who hits by temperament on the hour of Bologna, and Machiavelli does not say that he deserved success in one case and not in the other. His virtù is, in the end, that of having the right way for the right hour, and the book tells how rare that is.
Relationships
- Cesare Borgia: the duke who should have prevented his election, the only error the book points out in him.
- Alexander VI: the predecessor whose blows against the barons of Rome left the road open and the Church great.
- Ferdinand of Aragon: the king of Spain with whom he allied against France in Chapter XIII, and who was negotiating with France over Bologna in Chapter XXV.
- Louis XII: the king of France whom he drags behind him in the enterprise against Bologna and whom he afterward fights without levying an extraordinary tribute.
- Lorenzo de' Medici: the dedicatee of the book, whose uncle, Leo X, inherits the pontificate that Julius left.