Who He Is
The lawyer is the guest at the dinner at Cardinal Morton's house who opens the discussion of theft in Book I. The book gives him no name: he is a lay lawyer, that is, not a cleric, who praises English justice for hanging thieves, as many as twenty on a single cross, and is amazed that so many are still left. He represents the man who knows the law as it is and defends it because it is law. What he wants is for severity to be maintained, and what he knows is the practice of the court, not the causes of crime. When Raphael Hythloday answers that the penalty does not stop those who have no other means of living, the lawyer does not discuss the argument: he prepares to answer in the manner of the schools, and is silenced only because the cardinal cuts him off. That is his role in the book, that of the adversary who does not need to convince anyone, because the room follows him.
Trajectory
In Book I, Section 3, he speaks first. He praises the gallows and wonders that so many thieves remain. Hythloday answers that the punishment is too cruel and does not solve anything, and points to the causes of theft: maimed soldiers, nobles who dismiss their retainers, enclosures for raising sheep.
It is too atrocious to avenge thefts and yet insufficient to restrain them.
When Hythloday concludes that justice manufactures thieves in order to punish them, the lawyer prepares to answer in the manner of the schools, but Cardinal Morton interrupts him and asks for the alternative. Hythloday describes the Polylerites, and the lawyer says that this would put the republic in danger. Everyone goes over to his side, until the cardinal proposes trying it.
what all had scorned when I told it, the same all, vying with one another, began to cover with praises
In Book I, Section 4, the episode is the proof that Hythloday uses against the council of kings: if a good idea passes only when the lord blesses it, whoever is not the lord speaks to the wind.
Themes Embodied
The lawyer embodies Justice and Law from the point of view of the court, which measures justice by punishment. He belongs to Politics on the side of the court, where the opinion of the powerful decides, and touches Money and Wealth through the depths of the discussion: the crime he wants to see punished with death is theft, the "small coin taken" that Hythloday speaks of.
The text does not show him as wicked, only as sure of himself. Two readings fit. In one, it is the reason of the trade: whoever deals with the law every day sees no reason to change it, and that is why the danger he points to in the alternative is that of one who fears the unknown. In the other, he is a man who merely follows the atmosphere: when the cardinal says to try it, everyone begins to praise the idea, the lawyer with them, without the book saying whether he changed his mind. The book tells it without resolving it.
Relationships
- Raphael Hythloday: the adversary, who answers that the gallows fails in its own aim and that the punishment makes more thieves.
- Cardinal Morton: the host who cuts him off and later proposes trying the alternative.
- Thomas More and Peter Giles: the listeners of the account, who know the lawyer only through Hythloday's voice.