Who They Are
The Utopians are the people of the island, and the book treats them as a single character: fifty-four cities identical in language, customs, institutions and laws, so that whoever knows one knows them all. None of them has a name or speaks for himself. The one who describes them is Raphael Hythloday, who lived among them more than five years. They appear as a people who work six hours a day, eat in common halls, take what they need from the storehouses without paying, despise gold, abhor war and wage it with money, and let each person believe what he likes, except to deny Providence and the immortality of the soul. What they want, according to the text, is the maximum free time from the servitude of the body for the liberty and cultivation of the mind, and in this they judge happiness to consist. What they know came to them from afar: they learned from shipwrecked Romans and Egyptians, and in three years they learned the Greek that the Europeans brought them.
Trajectory
The Utopians have no plot, they have customs, and the book goes through them in order. In Book II, Section 1, they appear as farmers, not lords of the land, who take turns in the countryside for two years. In Book II, Section 2, they live in houses with doors that have no lock, exchanged by lot every ten years, and compete street by street in the care of their gardens.
In Book II, Section 3, they elect syphogrants, tranibors and a prince for life, and forbid discussing public affairs outside the senate. In Book II, Section 4, they work six hours and sleep eight, and the rest of the day is each person's own.
For that is an affliction worse than slavery, and yet it is almost everywhere the life of artisans, except among the Utopians. They divide the day, counting the night, into twenty-four equal hours, and assign only six to work
In Book II, Section 5, they eat in halls, care for the sick in public hospitals and take from the storehouses without money what they need. In Book II, Section 6, they travel with permission and are at home everywhere, but there is nowhere to idle.
In Book II, Section 7, they share abundance among the cities without charging and use gold for the most squalid vessels.
Thus the whole island is like a single family.
In Book II, Section 8, they study and distinguish true pleasure from false. In Book II, Section 9, they have very few laws, without pettifoggers, and slaves who are, in general, convicts. In Book II, Section 10, they abhor war but wage it, and pay foreigners to fight.
In Book II, Section 11, they follow several religions and give the supreme being a common name, Mithras.
they judge that there is a supreme being, to whom the work of the universe and providence are owed. All call him in common, in the language of their country, Mithras.
In Book II, Section 11, each one gives thanks, in the common prayer, for having fallen into the best republic and the truest religion. In Book II, Section 12, Hythloday says that, where nothing is private, everyone is rich.
Themes Embodied
The Utopians carry Happiness, which the book discusses in Section 8, in separating true pleasure from false, and in Section 4, in speaking of free time. They carry Work and Vocation, with the chosen trade, the rotation in the country and the short working day, and Money and Wealth, with life without coinage, the scorned gold and the shared abundance.
The book shows a faceless people, and that is what makes Utopia work as an example: the order appears without people who sustain it or oppose it. Two readings fit. In one, it is proof that a well-ordered people lives well. In the other, it is a description in which no one but Hythloday speaks, in which the equality of language, custom and law is complete and what life like this costs each person the text does not say. More's ending, in which he would wish for much of what he heard without expecting to see it, leaves both readings standing.
Relationships
- Raphael Hythloday: the one who lived among them and describes them from end to end, in a tone of praise.
- Utopus: the founder who led them from rude to cultured, and from whom they inherit the canal and the tolerance.
- Thomas More and Peter Giles: Hythloday's listeners, who do not know them and judge them by the account.
- Cardinal Morton and the Lawyer: the figures of Book I who defend the gallows for theft, in contrast with the island, where almost every serious crime leads to slavery and not to death.