Clavis Libri

Character

Thomas More

Who He Is

Thomas More, the character, is the narrator of the book: the one who writes the opening letter, who meets the traveler in Antwerp and who closes the work. The book presents him as a citizen of London, sent by King Henry VIII to Flanders to settle disputes with the prince of Castile, and that is why he is in Antwerp when he meets Raphael Hythloday. Hythloday calls him Morus. Within the conversation he is the practical counterpoint: he wants learning to serve the common good, accepts staying close to power and lessening evil by an indirect route, and doubts that a republic without property could work. What he wants, in short, is to be useful without being naive. What he knows, and says, is that the world will not be changed all at once. What he keeps quiet about, in the end, is most of his objections.

Trajectory

In the Letter to Peter Giles, he presents himself as a mere reporter: he did not invent the matter, he repeated what he heard, and the simplicity of the style, he says, is proof of truth. He asks his friend to check the width of a bridge and to find out in what part of the world the island lies, and declares that he prefers to say a falsehood than to lie.

I will say a falsehood rather than lie, because I prefer to be good than to be prudent
Letter to Peter Giles: Thomas More to Peter Giles

In Book I, Section 1, he goes to Bruges with the ambassador Cuthbert Tunstall and, while the Flemings consult the prince, gets to know Peter Giles in Antwerp. Outside the church, he takes Hythloday for a ship's captain, and it is Peter who corrects him.

In Book I, Section 2, he argues that a man of such learning ought to put it to the service of public affairs, because from the prince a flood of goods and evils flows over the people.

For from the prince, as from a perennial spring, a flood of all goods and all evils flows over the whole people.
Book I, Section 2: Raphael's Travels

In Book I, Section 3, he is the listener of the dinner that Hythloday tells of, at the house of Cardinal Morton, where he was raised, and the memory makes him a boy again.

In Book I, Section 4, he defends the "more civil philosophy": to know the stage and play the part of the play being performed, instead of reciting Seneca in a comedy. If the evil cannot be cured, he says, at least make it as small as possible. He does not accept that one can live well without property and answers that no one would work, and there would be sedition.

And what you cannot turn to good, at least make it as little bad as possible.
Book I, Section 4: The Philosopher and the Counsel of Kings

In Book II, Section 12, after Hythloday's praise, he lists what seemed absurd to him, war, religion and above all life without money, and falls silent. He praises the discourse, takes the traveler in to supper and confesses that there is much in Utopia that he would wish to see in the cities of his own time.

Meanwhile, though I cannot agree with everything that was said, by a man who is without doubt most learned and at the same time most expert in human affairs, I readily confess that there are very many things in the commonwealth of the Utopians that I would rather wish for than expect to see in our own cities.
Book II, Section 12: The Praise of the Republic and More's Reply

Themes Embodied

More embodies Politics from the inside: he is the one who says that the philosopher should try to serve. He also carries Truth and Lies, because his letter is the first place where the book plays with what can or cannot be checked, and Friendship, because the whole Antwerp scene is made of conversation between friends.

The character disagrees with Hythloday and then praises him, and the text leaves the two attitudes side by side. In one reading, it is the prudence of one who knows the court and does not want to abandon ship in the storm. In the other, it is the courtesy of one who, with his guest tired, prefers supper to argument, and who in the end says only "would wish," not "would adopt." The book does not resolve which of the two is his, and what More says of himself in the letter, that he prefers to be good than to be prudent, points to both.

Relationships

  • Raphael Hythloday: the traveler he listens to, with whom he discusses the council and property and whom he takes in to supper.
  • Peter Giles: the friend from Antwerp, to whom he writes the letter and who introduces the traveler to him.
  • Cardinal Morton: the chancellor in whose house he was raised, remembered by Hythloday and by him.
  • The Lawyer: a figure of the cardinal's dinner whom he knows only through Hythloday's account.
  • Utopus and the Utopians: the founder and the people of the island, whom he knows only through Hythloday's discourse and about whom he keeps objections that he does not voice.