Clavis Libri

Character

Cardinal Morton

Who He Is

Cardinal Morton is the host of the dinner that Raphael Hythloday tells of in Book I: Archbishop of Canterbury and Chancellor of England, in whose house Thomas More was raised. Hythloday paints him as a man who made himself respected without making himself feared, expert in the law, of prodigious memory, who liked to put petitioners to the test to see each one's presence of mind. Within the scene, he is the authority who decides: he is not the one who speaks most, but his is the face that the table follows. What he wants, there, is a reasonable solution to theft, and that is why he cuts off the lawyer who was about to answer in the manner of the schools and asks Hythloday for the alternative. What is seen, in the scene Hythloday tells, is the power of an idea that the chancellor blesses: he only has to say "let it be tried" for the whole room to change sides.

John Morton (c. 1420 to 1500) was Archbishop of Canterbury from 1486, Chancellor of England under Henry VII and a cardinal from 1493. More lived in his house as a page in his youth.

Trajectory

He appears in a scene only in Book I, Section 3. First, when the lawyer praises the justice that hangs as many as twenty thieves on a single cross, the cardinal answers that such people serve in war, and Hythloday retorts that France, full of mercenaries, shows the danger of raising such beasts.

It is too atrocious to avenge thefts and yet insufficient to restrain them.
Book I, Section 3: At Cardinal Morton's Table

Later, when Hythloday describes the alternative of the Polylerites and the lawyer says that it would put the republic in danger, the cardinal suggests trying it, postponing the execution, and extends the idea to vagabonds. It is then that everyone praises what they had scorned.

what all had scorned when I told it, the same all, vying with one another, began to cover with praises
Book I, Section 3: At Cardinal Morton's Table

At the end, when the jester and the friar trade barbs, he smiles at the joke and turns the conversation aside. In Book I, Section 4, he is remembered: Morus says that he liked the account and that it took him back to the house where he was raised, and Hythloday uses the dinner as proof of what would become of him at court, where a good idea passes only if the lord blesses it.

Themes Embodied

The cardinal embodies power in its commonest use, that of one who decides what is worth something by the face he makes. He also stands in Justice and Law, because he is the one who presides over the conversation in which it is discussed whether theft deserves the gallows, and in Politics, through the scene Hythloday chooses to prove what happens to a counselor who is not the lord.

The text does not show the cardinal as a villain. Hythloday describes him with praise and tells that he proposed trying the idea. Two readings fit. In one, the cardinal is the rare powerful man who listens and lets himself be persuaded, and that is why the table bows to good counsel. In the other, the fact that the room approves only when he approves shows what power does to conversation, even in the hands of a good man. The book tells both things and does not choose.

Relationships

  • Raphael Hythloday: the guest who lays out for him the causes of theft and from whom he asks an alternative to the gallows.
  • Thomas More: the boy raised in his house, who remembers the dinner with fondness.
  • The Lawyer: the guest who praises the gallows and whom the cardinal cuts off.
  • Peter Giles: the listener, with More, of what Hythloday tells.