What It Is
The severed isthmus is the canal that Utopus orders dug at the point where the land joined the continent, and which makes the region an island. Before that, the place was called Abraxa. The founder, newly victorious, digs fifteen miles, lets the sea run around, and in a single stroke separates the people from the rest of the world. It is the first act of government on the island, and it is an act of isolation. The book tells it in few words, and the reader hears in them the founding gesture of all of Utopia: before it can be an order, the island must be a closed place.
Where It Appears
The scene is in Book II, Section 1, right after Raphael Hythloday describes the shape of the island, the rocks and the channels that only the Utopians know.
he had fifteen miles dug in the part where the land joined the continent, and made the sea flow around the land.
Utopus does not force only the inhabitants: he joins to them all his soldiers, so that no one would take the labor as an insult, and the work is finished quickly, to the amazement and fear of the neighbors, who had laughed at the idea.
For this work he forced not only the inhabitants (so that they would not take the labor as an insult), but joined to them all his soldiers.
The effects of the canal reappear in the same section, in the defense: the bay can only be crossed with a Utopian guide, and a few defenders hold off an army. The island the cut produced has fifty-four identical cities, and each considers itself more a farmer than a lord of the land.
No city has any desire to enlarge its boundaries. For, as to the lands they possess, they judge themselves rather its farmers than its lords.
The isolation returns in Book II, Section 6, which regulates travel: whoever leaves the limits without the prince's permission is brought back as a fugitive and punished, and whoever repeats it falls into slavery.
What It Means
The severed isthmus means that the order of Utopia begins with a border. The canal is a gesture of security, and Hythloday explains it as such: an island with only one path known to its own people is an island that no one takes. But the cut is also a choice about the world outside, which the island will deal with cautiously, with a guide, with permission and, in war, with gold. The work shows that the first act of the best state was to withdraw it from the company of the others.
Hythloday tells of the canal from the point of view of defense, and the text does not say what the solitude costs the island. Two readings fit. In one, the cut is the reasonable precondition of any order: without a border, no institution lasts long enough to bear fruit. In the other, it is the sign that Utopia exists only apart, and that the best republic in the book is also the most closed and the one that most watches over who enters and who leaves. The book tells the fact and leaves it to the reader to weigh the two.
Relationships
- Standard themes: Politics, Work and Vocation.
- Characters: Utopus, the Utopians, Raphael Hythloday.
- Neighboring symbols: the bridge of Amaurot, the work that, in the city, takes the opposite path and joins two banks.