Clavis Libri

Symbol

The Landscape Painter

What It Is

The landscape painter is the image with which Machiavelli defends himself, in the Dedication, against the charge of presumption: a man of low condition dares to discourse on the governments of princes. The answer is that of those who draw landscapes: they place themselves on the plain to see the nature of the mountains and on a mountain to see the nature of the plain. It is an image of point of view, and it is with it that the dedication sustains the author's right to speak.

Where It Appears

The image appears in the paragraph in which the author foresees the objection.

to know well the nature of peoples one must be a prince, and to know well that of princes one must be of the people
Dedication: To Lorenzo de' Medici

Machiavelli uses it to say that, from inside, neither of the two sides is seen whole: whoever is below sees princes as the painter sees the mountains, from afar and entire, and whoever is above sees peoples as the painter sees the plain from the top of the mountain. That is why knowing peoples asks for the place of the prince, and knowing princes asks for the place of the people. The final paragraph of the Dedication closes the circle, when it asks the addressee, from the summit of his height, to turn his eyes now and then to the low places and see the malignity of fortune that the author endures without deserving it. The image, therefore, is the argument that justifies the book and also the request that closes it.

What It Means

The landscape painter means that political knowledge demands two positions, and that whoever has only one sees only a part. Power is seen better from below, and the people are seen better from above. The sentence gives the man without office a quality that the prince lacks, that of looking from outside, and it is with this that Machiavelli maintains that his advice is worth having: not because it comes from someone who governs, but because it comes from someone who observes the government from a position that the ruler does not occupy.

The text supports two readings. In one, the image is an honest defense of the view from below, and what the author offers is that distance. In the other, it is a formula of courtesy: the dedication is a request to one who holds power, and the comparison with the painter makes the request look like a service. The image works in both, and the reason is the same as in the rest of the book: Machiavelli needs a reason to speak, and the argument from point of view is, at once, a defense and an offer.

Relationships

  • Standard themes: Politics, Power.
  • Characters: Machiavelli, who places himself on the plain, and Lorenzo de' Medici, whom he asks to look at the low places.
  • Neighboring symbols: the river of fortune, because fortune is the word with which the dedication ends.