What It Is
The river of fortune is the image with which Machiavelli explains, in Chapter XXV, how much fortune can do in human affairs: he compares her to a destructive river that, when it rages, floods the plains, tears down trees and buildings, carries earth from one place and sets it down in another, and before which everyone flees. The river is not an enemy to be fought. It is a force whose damage depends on whether there was preparation, and for that reason the image answers fatalism without denying the violence of the flood.
Where It Appears
The image is in Chapter XXV, and the whole chapter is organized around it. Many hold that the world is governed by fortune and by God in such a way that the prudence of men does not correct it. Machiavelli confesses that he partly inclines to that opinion, but judges that fortune may be the arbiter of half of our actions and leaves the government of the other half, or nearly so, to us, so that free will may not be extinguished. Then comes the river.
I compare her to a destructive river that, when it rages, floods the plains, tears down trees and buildings, carries earth from one place and sets it down in another; everyone flees before it, everyone yields to its fury, unable to resist it; and, although this is so, it does not follow that men, when the times are calm, cannot take precautions, with repairs and with dikes
The political consequence comes in the next sentence, and the diagnosis falls on Italy.
a plain without dikes and without any repair
Italy is the plain without dikes, unlike Germany, Spain and France, which have adequate virtù, and the flood that struck her would not have done what it did had she been protected.
The foreign invasions that the text calls a flood begin in 1494, when Charles VIII, king of France, comes down to Italy to take the Kingdom of Naples.
The same chapter adds a second image, fortune as a woman, who is won by beating her and pushing her about, and the two say different things: with the river, resistance comes beforehand, with dikes built in calm times; with the woman, it comes on the spot, with audacity. Chapter XXIV had already given the first sense, saying that the Italian princes who lost their states should not accuse fortune, but their own sloth, for never having thought in quiet times that things might change. In the Dedication, fortune appears also as the malignity that the author himself endures, and in Chapter XXVI, as the force that rebukes Italy's flashes of redemption.
What It Means
The river means that fortune is real and strong, but not all-powerful: her force is measured by what was done before her. The dikes are organized virtù, the preparation of one who, in calm times, thinks of the storm, and the lack of them is what Machiavelli charges against Italy. Hence the book's advice, which is not to resist the river, but to choose where it passes. Fortune becomes one part of what happens, and the other part stays in the hands of the one who governs.
The symbol has two readings that the chapter leaves together. In one, it is a thesis on free will put in the form of an image, that preparing is possible and worthwhile. In the other, it is a warning of modesty: no one stops the river, and the man who prospered yesterday can fall tomorrow without having changed his nature, because the times have changed. Machiavelli does not choose between the two and ends up preferring impetuosity to caution, but the image of the dike remains as the gesture that precedes it: what is done in calm is what decides the flood.
Relationships
- Standard themes: Fate and Free Will, Power.
- Characters: Julius II, the example from Chapter XXV of one who hit on the time through impetuosity; Cesare Borgia, that of one who foresaw everything but illness; Machiavelli, who divided actions between fortune and us.
- Neighboring symbols: the landscape painter, because fortune is the last word of the dedication that the painter justifies.